z*****a
发帖数: 1214 | 1 来自主题: Immigration版 - 律师推荐 没经验，不过读各位律师的文章，觉得LiuLaw的文章最靠谱，不知道他手下的人怎么样
。 |
|
|
l**w
发帖数: 865 | 3 1A or 1B?
liulaw 的文章说的很清楚，建议读一度 |
|
|
T*******y
发帖数: 6523 | 5 It may be okay for EB1B:
http://www.mitbbs.com/ym_article/LiuLaw/31076389.html
But definitely not for EB1A.
However, if you have enough material to claim 2 or 3 times, you may not need
this media report, to save some hassle and potential RFE, etc. If you have
multiple media reports to make it a strong claim, then you can definitely
claim it altogether. |
|
x*****l
发帖数: 137 | 6 恭喜恭喜！
能告诉我是Liulaw的那个律师办理的？
谢谢！
(
子。 |
|
e******h
发帖数: 101 | 7 律师说“他引”可以算成 “媒体报道-published material in professional
publications written by others about the alien’s work in the academic field”
我深表怀疑！
但在网上看了一下，特别是这个：
http://www.mitbbs.com/ym_article/LiuLaw/31076389.html
貌似也不是全无可能，全无道理。
请教各位怎么看？别人引用我paper，算“媒体报道”的一种吗？谢谢！ |
|
M***y
发帖数: 114 | 8 想问下大家，liu 律师服务怎么样？
从版上文章看，我的印象是他接case比较谨慎，那是不是意味着他的通过率很大？有没
有近100%啊？
我看他的premium service好像连推荐信都他们起草。效果可好？
他们通常准备起来快吗？一般要多久会准备好提交？
有没有可能出错？我看到有的人抱怨律师填表格有错误之类。 |
|
g*****3
发帖数: 455 | 9 liu 不是接CASE谨慎，而是当他手头的CASE很多时，他的EVALUATION 的标准就出奇得
高。我曾让他评估过，他说 “After carefully reviewing your record, we
regret that our office is not able to .... due to ...... please consult
with other lawyers who may have a different opinion about the case.”
I then consulted with another lawyer and my case was approved without RFE.
Accepting only very strong cases does not mean he is a good immigration
lawyer but only mean the case is strong.没有听说过 “他的通过率很大“。
Go consult with other lawyers...... |
|
a****d
发帖数: 624 | 10 看得我心理平衡多了，我也被他拒绝了。
The citations and reviewer work are on the lower side of USCIS approved EB-
1A cases. The case will have a chance to be approved, but due to moderate
citations and reviewer work, we are not able to estimate the likelihood of
success. For this reason, we regret that we are not able to work on this EB-
1A case at this time. Please consult with other lawyers who may have a
different opinion about the case. |
|
|
a****d
发帖数: 624 | 12 人家名气大，生意肯定好。我们这种小弱case只有被惨无人道拒绝得份！ |
|
|
e******r
发帖数: 9977 | 14 很多硫痨不收的case也过了。。
不过我对伊印象不错，起码免费评估回信超快，而且在评估里指点了我一二。
非硫粉，我diy |
|
|
e******r
发帖数: 9977 | 16 可能那是对别人，我是弱case穷人diy尚无果。 |
|
|
|
a****d
发帖数: 624 | 19 问了来share一下啊，我也在头疼，弱小case， NIW有等于无，eb1a实在是没有把握。
不知道找那个律师能有点帮助呢 |
|
e***d
发帖数: 734 | 20 我当初也是被liu拒了，建议我还是走niw就好
不过拒我的不止他一个，事实上我问了一圈，除了一个律师别人都把我拒了= = |
|
m***c
发帖数: 637 | 21 frankly, liu is a good lawyer, but he will not boast your materials too much
. Therefore, if you background is not strong, please don't go. Your finally
application will be weaker than your background. For many background, he
will think that is not qualified to file.
I read one of my friend's application filed by liu law, I have to say it is
really terrible, and it is the worst application I read, even worse then DIY
without any EB1a knowledge.
I read many cases, including applications from 4 la... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
|
|
f****i
发帖数: 62 | 25 我最近也找刘律师评估了一下，得到如下结论：
this EB-1A case should have a reasonable chance to be approved under normal
circumstances.
不知道各位大牛怎么看我这个Case得到批准的可能性，请大家多多指教 |
|
c******g
发帖数: 9273 | 26 你这个是show off 啊。刘律师给这个结论的都是大牛人
normal |
|
a****d
发帖数: 624 | 27 The citations and reviewer work are on the lower side of USCIS approved EB-
1A cases. The case will have a chance to be approved, but due to moderate
citations and reviewer work, we are not able to estimate the likelihood of
success
那Liu Law对我的case的结论如上，还有机会吗？ |
|
T*******y
发帖数: 6523 | 28 Okay, here's the quantitative metric that Zac Liu used in his evaluation:
1. "Excellent chance" for those that the chance of approval is 90%~99%;
2. "Fairly good chance" for those that the chance of approval is 80%~89%.
3. "Reasonable chance" for those that the chance of approval is 60%~79%.
4. "Substantial risk" for those that the chance to be approved is below 60%. |
|
T*******y
发帖数: 6523 | 29 I should also add that other lawyers may refrain from giving any numerical
evaluations at all, since this number may be misleading, as a higher number
may make an applicant expect too much and a lower number may make him/her
lose confidence.
In reality, everybody has a chance, and give it your best try!
%. |
|
|
T*******y
发帖数: 6523 | 31 kaka,"甄古诗", very cool name! It used up dozens of my brain cells to figure this out. :-)
To back it up on what I said, those numbers were what Liu told me when I asked him what he meant exactly. |
|
M***y
发帖数: 114 | 32 cool. 我有level2的chance。可惜我还是决定先不申请了，我明年4月份还要申请F1延
期。:(
number |
|
T*******y
发帖数: 6523 | 33 Have you got your documents almost ready? It often takes three months to get all the letters and print-outs ready. If you are ready now, you can probably get your green card or at least the EAD by next April, then you don't need to renew your OPT (if this is what you meant by F1) any more. If you are not on your OPT, but just purely F1, then probably you can wait till you work to apply for a green card, to be on the safe side.
延: 期。:( |
|
n******1
发帖数: 319 | 34 其实我想问：他的case多不就表示他牛么。。。。
如果平白一个律师说我只接强case，谁买账啊 |
|
n******1
发帖数: 319 | 35 really terrible是什么意思？
为什么是worst application
much
finally
is
DIY |
|
M***y
发帖数: 114 | 36 我要申请的是NIW,还要等排期的，所以估计到明年是拿不到EAD的吧？
我现在是pure F1,还没有opt，明年是想延长我的I-20上的那个时间。毕业估计在明年
底，到时候还要申请OPT。
我们学校ISSS这段时间刚好请了个律师过来讲移民，叫arthur serratelli,有没有人听
说过？他怎么样？据他说，I-20延期是绝对不会有问题，OPT申请，只要人在美国，也
不太会有问题。所以，我现在又开始想申请了。
get all the letters and print-outs ready. If you are ready now, you can
probably get your green card or at least the EAD by next April, then you don
't need to renew your OPT (if this is what you meant by F1) any more. If you
are not on your OPT, but just purely F1, then probably you can w... 阅读全帖 |
|
T*******y
发帖数: 6523 | 37
You are right, NIW needs to wait. What I talked about was for EB1.
年底，到时候还要申请OPT。我们学校ISSS这段时间刚好请了个律师过来讲移民，叫
arthur serratelli,有没有人听说过？他怎么样？据他说，I-20延期是绝对不会有问题
，OPT申请，只要人在美国，也不太会有问题。所以，我现在又开始想申请了。
I don't know the answer to this F1 or OPT question. Well, given current PD
of NIW, it might be quicker for you to get a green card if you apply for EB1
in 2013 than applying for NIW now. I could be wrong, though. If the EB2 PD
is greatly moved ahead after dealing with that 2007 batch, it could be fast
i... 阅读全帖 |
|
f*****r
发帖数: 300 | 38 I think I-20 extension is done within your university. OPT? I also think it
's not a big deal.
don
you |
|
a****d
发帖数: 624 | 39 The case will have a chance to be approved, but due to moderate citations
and reviewer work, we are not able to estimate the likelihood of success.
For this reason, we regret that we are not able to work on this EB-1A case
at this time. Please consult with other lawyers who may have a different
opinion about the case。
楼上的，我和你的答复是一膜一样的。
总不能因为liu说了不行，我们自己就完全放弃了吧。 |
|
h********F
发帖数: 484 | 40 From Liu Law:
The information given to me in your email indicates that you are eligible to
apply for a green card through national interest waiver (NIW Eb-2) and
through Eb-1A.
Good or not? |
|
e******r
发帖数: 9977 | 41 about 60-79% success rate
to |
|
d********m
发帖数: 102 | 42 我的是
“this EB-1A case will have a fair chance to be approved under normal
circumstances”
fair 和 resonable 的区别是什么？
%. |
|
T*******y
发帖数: 6523 | 43 I really don't know the differences between such subtle wordings. If you
really want to know what Liu meant, you could ask him. That's how I got his
explanations earlier.
In one way, the numerical evaluation and its associated wording may help
people gain a better understanding of their cases. However, in another way,
this evaluation really limits people's thinking.
Being 70% or 80% probable, does it make much difference in your case's
preparation or the final result? If Liu said risky, would yo... 阅读全帖 |
|
s**********s
发帖数: 814 | 44 他给俺的评论是： The brief information given to me in your message
indicates a very promising EB-1A case. 不在这4个标准之内啊！
%. |
|
|
T*******y
发帖数: 6523 | 46 Asking the PI for a letter was what I meant earlier. But asking another
new letter on your work's impact to their work is surely also helpful.
I noticed that you have got a NIW RFE as well, right? I didn't read your
post on that fully, were the RFEs similar? I am asking because just now
I read this article from Zac Liu:
AAO推翻移民局决定，支持文章共同作者
http://www.mitbbs.com/ym_article/LiuLaw/31076403.html
It seems that NIW only request "significant or crucial contribution",
but not "major or primary contribu... 阅读全帖 |
|
w*********m
发帖数: 4740 | 47 http://www.mitbbs.com/ym_article/LiuLaw/31076403.html
“现代科研的合作性质决定了一篇文章会有多个共同作者。
每个共同作者均可能对文章中的研究结果有“实质性或关键性的贡献”（significant
or crucial contribution）。而且，在本案中，申请人已经提交了充分的证据证明自
己对文章有“关键性贡献”。同样重要的是，有关NIW的法律并不要求申请人象第一作
者那样对文章做出“主要贡献”（major or primary contribution）。相反，申请人
只需要证明自己对文章做出了实质性或关键性贡献。移民局要求申请人必须作为第一作
者做出“主要贡献”，是运用了错误的法律标准。” |
|
w*********m
发帖数: 4740 | 48 http://www.mitbbs.com/ym_article/LiuLaw/31076403.html
“现代科研的合作性质决定了一篇文章会有多个共同作者。
每个共同作者均可能对文章中的研究结果有“实质性或关键性的贡献”（significant
or crucial contribution）。而且，在本案中，申请人已经提交了充分的证据证明自
己对文章有“关键性贡献”。同样重要的是，有关NIW的法律并不要求申请人象第一作
者那样对文章做出“主要贡献”（major or primary contribution）。相反，申请人
只需要证明自己对文章做出了实质性或关键性贡献。移民局要求申请人必须作为第一作
者做出“主要贡献”，是运用了错误的法律标准。” |
|
a***y
发帖数: 40 | 49 RD: 07/21/2011
AD: 10/14/2011
背景:
1. US 美国一般学校ME Ph.D，现在一大公司做engineer
2. 6 journal (5 first author)；若干会议paper，1 第n作者patent
3. 引用当时包括自引是86个，现在增加到106
4. 推荐信 美国4封，加拿大1封，欧洲1封，其中只有加拿大和欧洲的是独立推荐
5. Review会议加journal一共9个左右
请的LiuLaw的Kellie，还比较满意，有问必答，提的建议也比较中肯。
最后有个问题请教大家：公司同意办Eb1b了，但是材料给了公司的律师4个月了还没有
任何动静，不知道何年何月能递出去。公司说如果老板同意或者我自己出钱可以PP。我
这样的情况PP到TSC的话RFE的可能性大吗？所有的材料基本都用了，实在没有精力再去
找推荐信之类的了。谢谢 |
|
a***y
发帖数: 40 | 50 RD: 07/21/2011
AD: 10/14/2011
背景:
1. US 美国一般学校ME Ph.D，现在一大公司做engineer
2. 6 journal (5 first author)；若干会议paper，1 第n作者patent
3. 引用当时包括自引是86个，现在增加到106
4. 推荐信 美国4封，加拿大1封，欧洲1封，其中只有加拿大和欧洲的是独立推荐
5. Review会议加journal一共9个左右
请的LiuLaw的Kellie，还比较满意，有问必答，提的建议也比较中肯。
最后有个问题请教大家：公司同意办Eb1b了，但是材料给了公司的律师4个月了还没有
任何动静，不知道何年何月能递出去。公司说如果老板同意或者我自己出钱可以PP。我
这样的情况PP到TSC的话RFE的可能性大吗？所有的材料基本都用了，实在没有精力再去
找推荐信之类的了。谢谢 |
|
