z*******a
发帖数: 175 | 1 i am not interested in judging zou. but the truth behind media reports is
attractive. that is why we are doing
science for living. also i hope chinese scientists all learn a lesson from
this big wave.
now respond to your maybes:
experiments
1st retraction was in march 2008. it should not take zou so long to repeat
his own one or two key
experiments for the retracted nature paper
i have no comments and no interests in this kind of things
science
i cannot image one would do anything else before ... 阅读全帖 |
|
p*****m
发帖数: 7030 | 2 zou第一片paper被retract的时候 zou所在的学校还有消息出来说系里强烈支持zou,zou
本人也号称在重复试验。等到现在3篇paper被retract了，首先zou去哪儿了？他已经离
开原来学校了（听说是回国继续混学术圈了） 他要是理直气壮也有证据 为啥非要离开
？如果他是觉得斗不过buck所以退让 那满可以干脆退出学术界 悄无声息回了吉林大学但是还继续在学术圈子 难道不
是心虚理亏的当然反应？ 其次从头到尾他有没有公开的出来说自己的paper data都是
没有问题的？把这些话公开说出来太简单了 不光是学术杂志了 就是local小报也会对
这种吵架新闻感兴趣的 不信你去查查当时Hellinga撤paper的时候 NatureScience的报
道是怎么替那个一作说话的。他一个字不说 一个声明不做 这种情况难道还应该一厢情
愿的相信zou?
同志 不用因为zou是个博后是弱势群体 linda buck是炸药奖是老板是强势群体 就一定
要自我代入的替zou说话吧？从头到尾哪个信息让你觉得有可能zou是被冤枉的？
experiments
maybe
science |
|
l**d
发帖数: 472 | 3 http://www.cnn.com/2011/HEALTH/01/05/autism.vaccines/index.html
Retracted autism study an 'elaborate fraud,' British journal finds
By the CNN Wire Staffc/div>
i/div>
v
Speaking to CNN's "Anderson Cooper 360," Wakefield said his work has been "
grossly distorted" and that he was the target of "a ruthless, pragmatic
attempt to crush any attempt to investigate valid vaccine safety concerns."
The now-discredited paper panicked many parents and led to a sharp drop in
the number of children getting th... 阅读全帖 |
|
G****P
发帖数: 21 | 4 刚在Pubmed里搜寻了"Retraction notice"，前面60 篇被retracted论文里有一半是国
人，2-3成是印度的。
望千老们引以为戒 |
|
|
s*******s
发帖数: 623 | 6 Genet Mol Res. 2011 Sep 30;10(3):2257.
RETRACTION of "Genetic and biochemical analyses of sensor kinase A in
Bacillus subtilis sporulation" by J.C. Nguele, P. Eswaramoorthy, M.
Bhattacharya, E. Ngou-Milama and M. Fujita. Genet. Mol. Res. 9 (1): 573-590
(2010).
[No authors listed]
Abstract
This paper has been retracted (without the consent of the submitting author,
Jean- Calvin Nguele) because of serious fraud and plagiary issues. The
submission letter, sent by Jean-Calvin Nguele, included forged... 阅读全帖 |
|
t******a
发帖数: 140 | 7 发信人: wxthl (huluhulu), 信区: TsinghuaCent
标 题: 中国大陆地区2006-2010撤稿文章分析(zz) ---浙大v5
发信站: 水木社区 (Wed Dec 7 15:41:07 2011), 站内
发信人: wxthl (huluhulu), 信区: NewExpress
标 题: 中国大陆地区2006-2010撤稿文章分析(zz)
发信站: 水木社区 (Wed Dec 7 15:36:51 2011), 站内
撤稿是科研工作中难以避免的一种现象，实验的误差、对照组的变异、统计方法的偏倚
，结果的片面分析……都会产生各种各样的“Bug”，导致作者或者主动，或者被动撤
稿，这是学术界的常态。我们通过按照时间顺序，通过pubmed统计了全球2006-2010年
的撤稿文章，发现总计有1000余篇撤稿文章，其中有99篇来自中国大陆地区（不含港澳
台地区），整体比例接近10%。非常有趣的是，2008年度中国SCI论文数首次突破10万篇
，位列世界第二位，仅次于美国，占全球份额的9.8%，也是接近10%的比例，这两个10%
相映成... 阅读全帖 |
|
t*d
发帖数: 1290 | 8 http://scienceblogs.com/erv/2011/12/xmrv_and_chronic_fatigue_sy
As it's Christmas, altogether for a sing-song to the tune of Oh Christmas
tree:
XMRV, XMRV
At last Science is Retracting
XMRV, XMRV
No more NIH distracting
With dodgy data, and made up figs
Paranoia and anti-Coffin digs
XMRV, XMRV
At last Science is Retracting! |
|
L*****C
发帖数: 157 | 9 http://the-scientist.com/2012/01/26/misconduct-called-out-on-yo
Misconduct Called Out on YouTube
A 6-minute video posted on YouTube documents more than 60 alleged cases of
image manipulation in 24 papers from a single researcher.
By Hannah Waters | January 26, 2012
In the latest instance of the scientific process taking place over the
internet, an anonymous internet-user has made a YouTube video exhibiting
more than 60 purportedly manipulated images from 24 papers, complete with
background music... 阅读全帖 |
|
l**********1
发帖数: 5204 | 10 Boston doctor selected to lead Texas cancer center
Print | Comments (8) Posted by Chelsea Conaboy May 11, 2011
According to a university press release, DePinho's wife, Dr. Lynda Chin, also will join the faculty of MD
Anderson. Chin is the scientific director of the Belfer Institute and professor of dermatology at Harvard
Medical School.
//www.boston.com/news/health/blog/2011/05/depinho_selecte.html
READER COMMENTS
>hedylamarr wrote:
"The couple were founders of Aveo Pharmaceutical, Inc., a publ... 阅读全帖 |
|
s******9
发帖数: 283 | 11 The peer review process at Science
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201011/cmselect/cmsc
1.Peer-reviewed scientific publications represent the primary useful archive
of scientific progress. Scientific publications have served other main
functions as well: They are a primary means of evaluating scientists and
institutions, and they have become a main pathway for informing the general
public about science, through coverage in the media and press releases (new
results are news). Peer-revi... 阅读全帖 |
|
i****g
发帖数: 3896 | 12 http://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-2237-598917.html
致《自然》杂志总编的信：有关叶诗文的新闻报道 精选
英文原信附后，大意如下：
斐尔,
你可能因Ewen Callaway对叶诗文的报道而被email狂炸，过去二十小时，给你
email的人里面小部分也给我来信。
如果你奇怪《自然》非本质部分一篇报道为何带来这么大的反应，你应该高兴
中文读者比世界其他读者更看重你们的新闻报道，与科学相关的（即使关系很小）也可
能重于《纽约时报》，中文媒体报道用你们的新闻也远多于一般西方媒体用你们的新闻。
Callaway报道最好也是草率、最差是种族偏见：1)最初的副标题暗示叶可能舞
弊; 2)Callaway用了两件事实说明叶惊人地异常，而两件都错了; 3)Callaway没咨询意
见不同的专家，导致报道不平衡，低于公平报道的最低标准。所以，Callaway至少不负
责任，可能太快就暗示中国运动员容易舞弊。他肯定没有达到新闻报道的通常标准。
我很高兴看到在我草拟此信的过程中，《自然》可能意识到了原副标题... 阅读全帖 |
|
b****y
发帖数: 81 | 13 strongly sp!
well done
http://blog.sciencenet.cn/blog-2237-598917.html
致《自然》杂志总编的信：有关叶诗文的新闻报道 精选
英文原信附后，大意如下：
斐尔,
你可能因Ewen Callaway对叶诗文的报道而被email狂炸，过去二十小时，给你
email的人里面小部分也给我来信。
如果你奇怪《自然》非本质部分一篇报道为何带来这么大的反应，你应该高兴
中文读者比世界其他读者更看重你们的新闻报道，与科学相关的（即使关系很小）也可
能重于《纽约时报》，中文媒体报道用你们的新闻也远多于一般西方媒体用你们的新闻。
Callaway报道最好也是草率、最差是种族偏见：1)最初的副标题暗示叶可能舞
弊; 2)Callaway用了两件事实说明叶惊人地异常，而两件都错了; 3)Callaway没咨询意
见不同的专家，导致报道不平衡，低于公平报道的最低标准。所以，Callaway至少不负
责任，可能太快就暗示中国运动员容易舞弊。他肯定没有达到新闻报道的通常标准。
我很高兴看到在... 阅读全帖 |
|
p*****m
发帖数: 7030 | 14 目前两天内收集到1100多签名，远远出乎我最早的预料（本来就是个人行动，后来有
Mitbbs网友愿意支持，我想有几十个支持就很好了）。计划明天伦敦工作日内发出。
抗议信也吸收了许多许多支持者的建议，尽量避免情绪化。但是我们还是不会拘泥于文章
的事实/逻辑问题，而会明白说出文章隐含的偏见色彩。我现在认为抗议本身也许能够
延伸出如何定义我们这个群体的public image,以及如何消除西方媒体民众对我们群体
image的stereotype的问题。当然这个不是小小一个抗议能起效的，明天我会写一个长
贴和大家讨论讨论
下面是抗议正式版:) 很多人的意见非常好，但是我没能力找出名字一一感谢了。。这
三天收了至少2000封email，回了1000封，还得给女儿喂奶哄睡，手快要断了:)
Dear Philip Campbell, Ph.D. and Editor-in-Chief of Nature,
We are a group of contributors, subscribers, and readers of Nature residing
in more than 20 countr... 阅读全帖 |
|
b******0
发帖数: 463 | 15 一个小想法，请斟酌：
最后一段这句中的"immediately"， "publicly" 位置我觉得应该移动下。
We urge Nature to retract this article and publicly apologize to Ye and all
athletes who may have been offended immediately.
-----〉
We urge Nature to retract this article immediately and apologize publicly to
Ye and all athletes who may have been offended.
文章 |
|
m**e
发帖数: 857 | 16 华人生物学家协会出面要求撤稿
http://www.cbisociety.org/
Nature should adhere to fact-based and unbiased reporting
Philip Campbell, Ph.D.
Editor-in-Chief, Nature
Dear Dr. Campbell:
We write on behalf of the Chinese Biological Investigators Society (CBIS) to
express our deep concern regarding a recent news article, titled "Why great
Olympic feats raise suspicions" (www.nature.com/news/why-great-olympic-
feats-raise-suspicions-1.11109, August 1, 2012), in which Ewen Callaway
discussed the performance of Ye Shiwe... 阅读全帖 |
|
s*******e
发帖数: 1544 | 17 我：(这是我的信的摘要，全文太长）I write this letter to raise the
possibility of misconducts in a clinical trial recently published in Am J
Clin Nutr September 2012 vol. 96 no. 3 658-664, entitled “ β-Carotene in
Golden Rice is as good as β-carotene in oil at providing vitamin A to
children”. In the abstract http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/96/3/658.abstract#fn-1, the authors mentioned that “This trial was registered at www.clinicaltrials.gov as NCT00680212.” The location mentioned in this trial, United Stat... 阅读全帖 |
|
a**y
发帖数: 464 | 18 It is unbelievable to see this nonsense comment here by a professor at a
certain university. Even if you has some problem with Schultz, it is unfair
to comment in such a way.
Schultz has made significant contributions on catalytic antibody, genetic
code expansion and cell reprograming, which has been widely accepted by the
scientific community. Also, several companies are using technologies
developed in his lab now - further confirming the use of his research.
Although in a few years ago, there ... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
G**s
发帖数: 21 | 20 Lead author of stem cell papers intends to retract study
TOKYO, March 14, Kyodo 10:49
A Japanese researcher who was the lead author of two recent papers on
potentially groundbreaking stem cell research and a couple of her co-authors
intend to withdraw the papers in response to allegations that they are
riddled with irregularities, sources close to the matter said Friday.
Haruko Obokata of the government-affiliated Riken institute and her co-
authors maintain, however, that they have succeeded in... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
s******y
发帖数: 28562 | 22 http://theconversation.com/nobel-laureate-weve-just-scraped-the
在最近一个访谈中，２００７诺奖获得者Martin Evans（由早期对胚胎干细胞以及转基
因老鼠的工作而获奖）对最近的两篇被retract的 Nature 上的干细胞文章（一篇是关
于物理压力，另外一篇是关于酸液）直言不谓的对Nature的editoral process表示不满
。并呼吁年轻科学工作者们不要全部相信文章上的所有说法而是要仔细看其中的数据并
做自己的独立判断。
Q: Reprogramming has also been in news notoriously recently. Two Nature
papers that showed that differentiated cells can be reprogrammed by physical
pressure or acid treatment were retracted this week. What’s your take on
that?
A: I was surprised... 阅读全帖 |
|
W*****3
发帖数: 727 | 23 是这么说的，有了IF=42,再多的retraction也阻挡不了要发nature的强烈愿望！
都是发生在2014年的事，只有IF在左右下一年的行情，retraction大概就是当成空气放
走了
非常符合商业利益，还能垄断广大男男女女的命运。 |
|
D**********a
发帖数: 4 | 24 Cell Biochem Biophys (2014) 70:703 DOI 10.1007/s12013-014-9880-0
RETRACTED ARTICLE: Effects of Osteopontin on Expression of IL-6 and IL-8 In&
#64258;ammatory Factors in Human Knee Osteoarthritis Chondrocytes
Weiwu Yao • Xiaodong Chen • De Li • Peng Wang •
Hanlong Xin • Jianhua Wang
The corresponding author and the first author retracted their article.
Due to an incorrect method used in the experiments the data cannot be
reproduced. |
|
a*******a
发帖数: 4233 | 25 http://news.sciencemag.org/asiapacific/2014/09/exclusive-nature
EXCLUSIVE: Nature reviewers not persuaded by initial STAP stem cell papers
As two discredited, and now retracted, stem cell papers have produced an
almost unimaginable fallout—a national hero accused of scientific fraud,
the revamping of one of Japan’s major research institutes, and the suicide
of a respected cell biologist—researchers have privately and publicly asked
how Nature could have published work that, in retrospect, seems ... 阅读全帖 |
|
d*****s
发帖数: 647 | 26 Nature. 2013 Nov 7;503(7474):146. doi: 10.1038/nature12727.
Retraction: Functional dissection of lysine deacetylases reveals that HDAC1
and p300 regulate AMPK.
Yu-yi Lin, Samara Kiihl, Yasir Suhail, Shang-Yun Liu, Yi-hsuan Chou, Zheng
Kuang, Jin-ying Lu, Chin Ni Khor, Chi-Long Lin, Joel S. Bader, Rafael
Irizarry & Jef D. Boeke
Nature 482, 251'255 (2012); doi:10.1038/nature10804
In response to a concern raised by a reader about inconsistencies in our
Letter between the results from the primary mi... 阅读全帖 |
|
s******y
发帖数: 28562 | 27 他们的意思是，神经突触的形成和记忆无关？
Reinstatement of long-term memory following erasure of its behavioral and
synaptic expression in Aplysia
Shanping Chen, Diancai Cai, Kaycey Pearce, Philip Y W Sun, Adam C
Roberts, David L GlanzmanCorresponding Author
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.03896Published November 17, 2014 Cite as eLife 2014;10.7554/eLife.03896 Download PDF
Abstract
Long-term memory (LTM) is believed to be stored in the brain as changes in
synaptic connections. Here, we show that LTM storage... 阅读全帖 |
|
g*********n
发帖数: 808 | 28 Alexandru S. Biris, the lead investigator on the retracted paper, was one of
seven winners of the 2011 faculty excellence award for research at the
University of Arkansas at Little Rock, where he leads the Center for
Integrative Nanotechnology Sciences.
Biris did not respond to several phone calls or email messages, and a
spokesperson for the university for UALR did not return calls for comment.
We’ll let you know if we find out more. In the meantime, we’ll remind
Retraction Watch readers that A... 阅读全帖 |
|
i*****i
发帖数: 154 | 29 This article has been retracted at the request of the authors. Donmez et al.
(2010) reported that SIRT1 suppressed Alzheimer’s disease in a mouse model
by upregulating the ADAM 10 α-secretase gene via coactivation of the
retinoic acid receptor, RARβ. Increased α-secretase bypassed the
processing of APP by the β-secretase, thereby reducing the amyloid burden.
It has come to our attention that several figures in the paper contain
images in which gel lanes were spliced together without appropriate
... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
w***7
发帖数: 1637 | 31 你地第一段话跟张一点关系都没有。那些话是网大地一个sb ID发地。
我地观点已经很明显了。张是人品有问题，刚开始我没看到证据，凭一些不太靠谱滴爆
料，不觉得张地文章应该被retract。但刚刚看到内幕地email，觉得张地问题比我之前
想象地更严重，文章是应该被retract。 |
|
l********n
发帖数: 260 | 32 最近检测一个基因表达在食道biopsy中，但是有人质疑这个基因表达在斑马鱼上做过，
并且保守表达在血液红细胞中。说我检测到表达是错误的。 但是已有很多报道在食管
癌中该基因表达紊乱。
我的方法是real-time PCR检测mRNA，由于样品小，提取蛋白的可能性没有了。
我需要问的是这个可能性怎么排除，文章发表了。居然让我retract paper。 说我的研
究给这个领域添乱了，不retract会误导后面的研究。还举例很多cell杂志上的
examples，几年后其他人发现是表达谱不对，给这个圈子添乱了。等等等等。。。。 |
|
l****y
发帖数: 486 | 33 她这个是HHMI early career investigator. 这个不是life time并且不renew的。她
2009当上的，现在即使还是也快到期了吧。她在08-09年申请这个时,paper retraction
应该还没开始吧。
她显然在过去几年一直都在compete HHMI investigator（early career investigator
中已经有后来当上investigator的了），但直到今年刚出来的这一批中都没她。应该
说paper retraction的事是有影响的。
这个early career investigator HHMI就搞了这一届，以后就不搞了。 |
|
l****y
发帖数: 486 | 34 刚查了一下，她的文章是2010年开始retract的，在她当上之后。在美国reputation还
是很重要的，我认为她很难再当上HHMI investigator.
retraction
investigator |
|
W*****n
发帖数: 21 | 35 Authors retract 2007 PNAS paper on aging due to figure’s “unintentional
anomalies”
with 15 comments
pnas 2515The authors of a 2007 PNAS paper that provided molecular details
for how calorie restriction may act on Sir2 enzymes to extend life are now
retracting their research after discovering a figure was compromised by “
several unintentional anomalies in the background image.”
According to study author David W. Piston at Vanderbilt University, first
author Qinghong Zhang cut and pasted images t... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 36 ►2016年5月2日，《自然·生物技術》在線發表了河北科技大學副教授韓春雨擔
任通訊作者的一篇論文，論文報導了一種新的基因編輯工具NgAgo可以在哺乳動物細胞
中使用。
● ● ●
過去幾個月，韓春雨論文結果的可重複性爭議引發公眾的巨大關注。
10月10日，12名（後增加1人變為13名）中國科學家通過媒體發表聲明稱無法重複或再
現韓春雨今年5月2日發表在《自然·生物技術》（Nature Biotechnology）的論文實驗
結果。
10月20日，《知識分子》獲悉，包括這12名科學家在內的多位中國科學家已經向《自然
·生物技術》期刊提交他們的實驗結果及批評意見。隨後，《知識分子》與《自然·生
物技術》取得聯繫，詢問他們是否已經接收到中國科學家的反饋意見。
ADVERTISEMENT
10月22日，《自然·生物技術》的一位新聞發言人回答了我們的問題。
►Q1: 你們是否收到了中國科學家提交的關於韓春雨等人發表在《自然·生物技
術》論文的批評意見？
A1：我們無法對收到的具體的反饋置評，但我們可以確認的是，我們已經收到了關於這
一文章的多個意見，並且已經考慮了或正在... 阅读全帖 |
|
i*********0
发帖数: 915 | 37 Cell Research上的一个AOP稿子。
Retraction: Defective heart development in hypomorphic LSD1 mice
Thomas B Nicholson, Hui Su, Sarah Hevi, Jing Wang, Jeff Bajko, Mei Li,
Reginald Valdez, Joseph Loureiro, Xiaodong Cheng, En Li, Bernd Kinzel, Mark
Labow and Taiping Chen
The authors unanimously wish to retract this paper because the calcium/
calmodulin-dependent protein kinase 2 (CamKII) was erroneously equated with
CK2 (Casein Kinase 2) throughout the paper. While all the results were valid
and supported th... 阅读全帖 |
|
j*******u
发帖数: 81 | 38 主要结论错误不retract的就没有见过。
一般作者自己发现错误会写个信correct，比如某一部分结论有误。 editor 酌情写一
个editoral concern。
但从头错到尾的一般都会retract。
技术类的文章主要结论站不住还发到nature biotech这个level的更是从来没有见过。 |
|
F*Q
发帖数: 3259 | 39 CNS上主意结论错误的文章不要太多了。我知道的没有一篇被撤稿，而且文章一样被引
用。
: 主要结论错误不retract的就没有见过。
: 一般作者自己发现错误会写个信correct，比如某一部分结论有误。 editor 酌
情写一
: 个editoral concern。
: 但从头错到尾的一般都会retract。
: 技术类的文章主要结论站不住还发到nature biotech这个level的更是从来没有
见过。
|
|
a****i
发帖数: 4783 | 40 这个方法挺好，先投稿，然后发表，然后申请法定，得到法定后retract，这样反正钱
到手了，而且印到白纸黑字的杂志上的文章是撤不掉了，今后还可以当做自己的
publication list，谁会去找某篇文章后来有没有retract记录。 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 41 RETRACTION of: Overexpression of VP, a vacuolar H+-pyrophosphatase gene in
wheat (Triticum aestivum L.), improves tobacco plant growth under Pi and N
deprivation, high salinity, and drought
Xiaojuan Li1*,
Chengjin Guo1*,
Juntao Gu2,
Weiwei Duan1,
Miao Zhao3,
Chunying Ma1,
Xiaoming Du2,
Wenjing Lu2† and
Kai Xiao1†
- Author Affiliations
1. 1 College of Agronomy, Agricultural University of Hebei, Baoding
071001, China
2. 2 College of Life Sciences, Agricultural University of Heb... 阅读全帖 |
|
c**i
发帖数: 265 | 42 居然是被撤稿 （the chief-in-editor retracted)，不是一般的主动撤稿 (the
authors retracted)。 |
|
w****e
发帖数: 776 | 43 1. http://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamaophthalmology/article-abstract/625824
May 1959
Unilateral Lid Retraction Without ExophthalmosA Manifestation of Thyroid
System Dysfunction
JOHN M. McLEAN, M.D.; EDWARD W. D. NORTON, M.D.
2. Chang EL , RubinPA. Upper and lower eyelid retraction.Int Ophthalmol
Clin. 2002;42(2):45–59.
please send to [email protected]/* */ Many thanks!!! |
|
发帖数: 1 | 44 【编者注】经本站检索，前10篇被撤论文第一作者的工作单位分别为：中南大学湘雅二
医院、浙江大学第一医院、复旦大学公共卫生学院、中国医科大学附属第四医院（沈阳
）、台州市立医院（2篇）、山东大学医学院、上海交通大学附属第六人民医院、华南
大学、第三军医大学第三附属医院（大坪医院）。这批被撤论文中显然有不少来自中国
的顶级医学院。
2016年，国家自然科学基金委员会曾开会通报，指2015年期间共有117篇涉及到中国作
者的论文被国际期刊撤稿。
https://www.letscorp.net/lynn/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/retraction-watch.
jpg
相关报道截图：《新记录：主流出版社从癌症期刊撤回100多篇同行评议造假的论文》
@扮虎：太丢人了！著名出版商斯普林格今天发布消息称，其治下的期刊《肿瘤生物学
》因为作者编造审稿人和审稿意见而撤稿107篇论文！全部都是中国作者，丢人丢大发
了！全晒在这里，有空找出来他们都是谁[怒]
@扮虎：这些论文作者用本领域专家的名字申请邮件地址，在这些... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
U**R
发帖数: 34 | 46 尘埃落定韩春雨? Nature Biotechnology 撤稿 NgAgo!
原创2017-08-03 知社 知社学术圈
海归学者发起的公益学术平台
分享信息，整合资源
交流学术，偶尔风月
北京时间8月3日，在经历过长达一年多的纷争和等待之后，Nature Biotechnology应韩
春雨等作者的要求，撤稿其发表于2016年5月的NgAgo论文。
从一鸣惊人到一波三折再到一声叹息，这一年多，中国学术界和韩春雨走过来了什么样
的历程？“身心疲惫”？NgAgo的争议，是否又就此尘埃落定？ 请看知社对这一里程碑
事件的回顾，和业内人士特约独家点评。
首先，我们来回顾一下NgAgo事件的主要发展过程与关键时间节点。
2014年2月，荷兰科学家John van der Oost在Nature杂志发表论文，报道TtAgo可以在
高温条件下体外切割DNA。韩春雨受到启发，开始利用Argonaut进行基因编辑，并在
2014年5月中旬取得关键突破。
2015年6月3日，韩春雨向Nature Biotechnology投稿。12月21日，浙江大学沈啸和韩春
雨提交“以Argonaute核酸酶为核心... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 47 首先，我们来回顾一下NgAgo事件的主要发展过程与关键时间节点。
2014年2月，荷兰科学家John van der Oost在Nature杂志发表论文，报道TtAgo可以在
高温条件下体外切割DNA。韩春雨受到启发，开始利用Argonaut进行基因编辑，并在
2014年5月中旬取得关键突破。
2015年6月3日，韩春雨向Nature Biotechnology投稿。12月21日，浙江大学沈啸和韩春
雨提交“以Argonaute核酸酶为核心的基因编辑技术”的专利保护申请。2016年3月21日
，Nature Biotechnology接收韩春雨的投稿，并在5月2日在线发表其题为DNA-guided
genome editing using the Natronobacterium gregoryi Argonaute论文。
2016年5月8日，多家知名微信公众号以一鸣惊人为题，先后报道韩春雨在极端艰苦与简
陋的条件下，做出世界级的科技成果，韩春雨首次进入大众视野，引发热议，并受到许
多媒体热捧。对于许多处于中国学术体制边缘地带的本土青年学者，韩春雨的成功具有
极大的励志效应，让很多人看... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 48 今天很早起来出差，没赶上今天的热点事件。晚上回来一看，这个话题火得不得了。感
觉不写点不好。就先查查媒体报道，看了半天，觉得国内中文媒体还算客气。如：
韩春雨回应主动撤回基因编辑论文:理解万岁
《自然》子刊发社论回应:韩春雨的研究仍有意义
韩春雨已从《自然-生物技术》撤回争议论文
但有一家网站的文章可不客气，直接用了这个词“academic fraud”。见：
Han Chunyu academic fraud dust settles? The manuscript of Nature...
www.bestchinanews.com/Science-Technology/12180.html
文章中下一段最不客气：“Finally, what we all care about is whether Han
Chunyu will face further treatment Five ministries recently severely
punished the authors involved in the 107 papers of "tumor biology". Ho... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
b**4
发帖数: 36 | 50 A group of chemical engineers in China has retracted their article on
photocatalysts after alerting the journal that images in the paper did not
show what they’d reported.
The article, which appeared in Catalysis Communications earlier this year,
was titled “Synthesis and characterization of novel Cu2O/PANI composite
photocatalysts with enhanced photocatalytic activity and stability,” and
was written by Xiufang Wang, Guangmei Chen and Jun Zhang of the School of
Materials and Chemical Engineering... 阅读全帖 |
|
