由买买提看人间百态

boards

本页内容为未名空间相应帖子的节选和存档,一周内的贴子最多显示50字,超过一周显示500字 访问原贴
Biology版 - 韩春雨的NgAgo幻影的破灭
相关主题
【记录历史】谁重复验证了NgAgo?总结2016.10.13 【记录历史】谁重复验证了NgAgo?
【记录历史】NgAgo’2016 – 第一阶段Milestones修订版zz颜宁对韩春雨的评论
【记录历史】NgAgo’2016 第二阶段 Milestones听说韩春雨的工作已经重复出来了
韩春雨的NgAgo效率怎么样?有人试过么?已经确认韩春雨是个骗子。
Nature News: The controversy over NgAgo韩春雨的电话录音
Google论坛上对韩春雨最新的质疑既然公开说韩春雨造假,就不要再披着马甲上阵了
韩春雨有没有隐瞒一些技术关键点以避免别人很快重复出来?看看老外怎么评价韩春雨的NgAgo
韩春雨提供给300个实验室的质粒同论文里的质粒不一致?韩春雨NgAgo的Nature Biotechnology存在篡改结果科学不端行为
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: ngago话题: cpf1话题: han话题: crispr话题: ki
进入Biology版参与讨论
1 (共1页)
c********6
发帖数: 693
1
韩春雨的NgAgo幻影的破灭,收起可怜的自尊心,坦然的接受现实。三流学校就是三流
,屌丝逆袭只能出现在电视剧中。这时候在美国某个不著名实验室阴暗角落里,一个从
国内三流大学毕业好不容易骗到一个postdoc职位的同学,心碎了。
w***a
发帖数: 4361
2
这个同学是你嘛?

【在 c********6 的大作中提到】
: 韩春雨的NgAgo幻影的破灭,收起可怜的自尊心,坦然的接受现实。三流学校就是三流
: ,屌丝逆袭只能出现在电视剧中。这时候在美国某个不著名实验室阴暗角落里,一个从
: 国内三流大学毕业好不容易骗到一个postdoc职位的同学,心碎了。

c********6
发帖数: 693
3
这个同学是本科毕业于国内三流院校的

【在 w***a 的大作中提到】
: 这个同学是你嘛?
I****p
发帖数: 101
4
这个ID有点阴暗,从头到尾就希望韩的工作是假的,如果你有亲自验证失败,我还服了
,不枉注册一个ID。

【在 c********6 的大作中提到】
: 韩春雨的NgAgo幻影的破灭,收起可怜的自尊心,坦然的接受现实。三流学校就是三流
: ,屌丝逆袭只能出现在电视剧中。这时候在美国某个不著名实验室阴暗角落里,一个从
: 国内三流大学毕业好不容易骗到一个postdoc职位的同学,心碎了。

c********6
发帖数: 693
5
请不要把他工作的真假跟我的ID扯上关系哦,还有至于他是否作假也不是由我希望或者
不希望左右的,不要一来就上纲上线给我扣这么大一顶帽子,我怕是承受不起哦。

【在 I****p 的大作中提到】
: 这个ID有点阴暗,从头到尾就希望韩的工作是假的,如果你有亲自验证失败,我还服了
: ,不枉注册一个ID。

F**M
发帖数: 11
6
中国小保方?如果真是假的,对中国生物科学研究有负面影响。
n******g
发帖数: 2201
7
but yitang zhang was real.

【在 c********6 的大作中提到】
: 韩春雨的NgAgo幻影的破灭,收起可怜的自尊心,坦然的接受现实。三流学校就是三流
: ,屌丝逆袭只能出现在电视剧中。这时候在美国某个不著名实验室阴暗角落里,一个从
: 国内三流大学毕业好不容易骗到一个postdoc职位的同学,心碎了。

H*******S
发帖数: 6
8
I do not care where the work was done and by whom, but the work should be
solid and repeatable.
To my surprise, so far, there is no any further publication following Han's
publication which was online on May 2nd 2016. This might be because of the
massive success of extensive application of CRISPR/Cas9 in genome editing.
Looking at the fate of Cpf1, which is called the "CRISPR 2.0", Zhang
published Cpf1 data in Oct 2015, since then there were not much further
articles regarding this protein, until this month (June 2016), there were
two brief reports on application of Cpf1 in generating KO/KI mouse models.
If NgAgo, confirmed by others to be what it is in the publication, we can
call it as "genome editor 3.0". We are still waiting for other labs to
repeat Han's work. We are also wait to see the application of NgAgo in
generating KO/KI mouse or other animal models.
By the way, NgAgo construct is available now from Addgene: http://www.addgene.org/78253/
My colleagues, if you want to prove sth, please go ahead doing it by
yourself, and with your data come back to tell us what is going on or I am
looking forward to reading your papers which supports or is against the
previous findings.
Declare: I am just curious to know any progress of NgAgo story instead of
criticizing anyone :)
n******7
发帖数: 12463
9
讨论NgAgo帖子里面怎么这么多马甲?
变态真多

s
你要么是心理变态,要么根本不是做研究的
还to my surprise
This might be because of the

【在 H*******S 的大作中提到】
: I do not care where the work was done and by whom, but the work should be
: solid and repeatable.
: To my surprise, so far, there is no any further publication following Han's
: publication which was online on May 2nd 2016. This might be because of the
: massive success of extensive application of CRISPR/Cas9 in genome editing.
: Looking at the fate of Cpf1, which is called the "CRISPR 2.0", Zhang
: published Cpf1 data in Oct 2015, since then there were not much further
: articles regarding this protein, until this month (June 2016), there were
: two brief reports on application of Cpf1 in generating KO/KI mouse models.
: If NgAgo, confirmed by others to be what it is in the publication, we can

1 (共1页)
进入Biology版参与讨论
相关主题
韩春雨NgAgo的Nature Biotechnology存在篡改结果科学不端行为Nature News: The controversy over NgAgo
【周末随笔】方舟子●张锋●韩春雨●水军Google论坛上对韩春雨最新的质疑
140个实验室重复韩春雨技术,只有仇子龙说成功了韩春雨有没有隐瞒一些技术关键点以避免别人很快重复出来?
"网红"学者韩春雨:正在持续实验 将适时公开验证韩春雨提供给300个实验室的质粒同论文里的质粒不一致?
【记录历史】谁重复验证了NgAgo?总结2016.10.13 【记录历史】谁重复验证了NgAgo?
【记录历史】NgAgo’2016 – 第一阶段Milestones修订版zz颜宁对韩春雨的评论
【记录历史】NgAgo’2016 第二阶段 Milestones听说韩春雨的工作已经重复出来了
韩春雨的NgAgo效率怎么样?有人试过么?已经确认韩春雨是个骗子。
相关话题的讨论汇总
话题: ngago话题: cpf1话题: han话题: crispr话题: ki