w***g
发帖数: 5958 | 1 不嫌丢人，贴个我今年拿到的review给大家平衡一下心理吧, USENIX ATC的。东西确实
做得不怎样，打算改投烂会了。
===== Strength =====
Simple idea to aid in bla bla. Well written paper.
===== Weakness =====
Idea is really simple; surprised it hasn't been done before. Lack of novelt
y.
===== Detailed Comments =====
It took a while to get to the real definition of bla bla. Initially I thoug
ht it more than it was, which is just bla blas. I'm surprised that this has
n't been done before. ... ...
naughtybag好歹出了个可以自己可以稍稍得意一下的结果。我做的东西连我自己都看不
上。不过我还 |
r********0
发帖数: 16 | |
w***g
发帖数: 5958 | 3 真是你写的？说实在四五个review就这个让我看了心里挺乐的。东西水平不够直接据了
就行，但有的reviewer非要给你找毛病。其实这些毛病都改了paper还是水平不够。
【在 r********0 的大作中提到】
: 哈哈，这个好像是我写的
|
C*********e
发帖数: 587 | 4 这个review感觉稍短了点，太泛泛了
novelt
thoug
has
【在 w***g 的大作中提到】
: 不嫌丢人，贴个我今年拿到的review给大家平衡一下心理吧, USENIX ATC的。东西确实
: 做得不怎样，打算改投烂会了。
: ===== Strength =====
: Simple idea to aid in bla bla. Well written paper.
: ===== Weakness =====
: Idea is really simple; surprised it hasn't been done before. Lack of novelt
: y.
: ===== Detailed Comments =====
: It took a while to get to the real definition of bla bla. Initially I thoug
: ht it more than it was, which is just bla blas. I'm surprised that this has
|
f*********g
发帖数: 632 | 5 小心他找出你来拍你。
【在 r********0 的大作中提到】
: 哈哈，这个好像是我写的
|
