m*****h 发帖数: 2292 | 1 【 以下文字转载自 Immigration 讨论区 】
发信人: BigTail (大尾巴), 信区: Immigration
标 题: 求助!TSC EB1B NOID received today
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Wed Dec 8 00:21:12 2010, 美东)
background:
engineering PhD, now work as a research scientist in a company
16+ publication (most of them are 1st author)
>130 citations
>30 reviews, served in the program committees of a few international
conferences
papers used by some professors as lecture material
one best paper award from a conference
8 reference letters (6 from U.S.), including a support letter from a
conference chair on my review experience
Claim:
authorship, contribution, review
IO是XM359,好像是TSC的Director。
140在6月交上去后一直没动静,实在忍不住了,11月file了PP。拖到第15天,XM359给
律师fax了个NIOD,根据2-step:
1. 承认3个criteria都符合了
2. 但你不够internationally recognized
所以决定拒你。
看完IO的NOID,有这么几条感想:
1.似乎IO没有意识到在CS领域conference的重要,翻来覆去提journal。似乎也没意识
到program committee member的重要性,而几份推荐信里已经强调过这个的重要性了。
2. 认为我的articles是moderately cited,不足以证明international recognized
3. 要求补充证明工作是innovative,而不是简单的replcate others' work。这个明明
推荐信里说了很多次,也列了几个citation sample来证明。
律师的petition letter我看过,所有的要点都写了,条理也不错。现在实在很迷惘,
不知道该补些什么材料?有没有同学好心share一下样本?
如果最后通过了,散尽包子答谢各位! | B*****l 发帖数: 192 | 2 居然转到这里来了。
有始有终吧:交完材料就批了。
【在 m*****h 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 【 以下文字转载自 Immigration 讨论区 】 : 发信人: BigTail (大尾巴), 信区: Immigration : 标 题: 求助!TSC EB1B NOID received today : 发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Wed Dec 8 00:21:12 2010, 美东) : background: : engineering PhD, now work as a research scientist in a company : 16+ publication (most of them are 1st author) : >130 citations : >30 reviews, served in the program committees of a few international : conferences
| m*****h 发帖数: 2292 | 3 cong
【在 B*****l 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 居然转到这里来了。 : 有始有终吧:交完材料就批了。
|
|