j*****x 发帖数: 3 | 1 不是天才,不要学张五常
■文/王则柯
如果张五常先生曾经这样走过来了并且成就为大师的话,当今世界已经没有你邯郸学步
的机会了。首先,谁叫你比张五常先生晚了半个世纪呢。第二,却是更重要的,谁叫你
不是张五常先生那样的天才呢?我敢断言,缺了这两个条件,特别是天才条件,张五常
的路就走不通。要知道,我们只是不比别人笨的凡人。即使会比别人勤奋一些,但还是
凡人,不是张五常那样的天才。
“张五常热”的合理性
“张五常热”在中国的出现,有它的合理性。他的“佃农理论”,是深刻的研究,此其
一;科斯(RonaldCoase)这样的经济学大师,奉他为罕有的知音,此其二。还可以有三
,有四。这些都是他耗用不完的本钱。其次,他思维敏捷,才华横溢,往往片言只语就
让人感觉他已经切中要害,不由得听众不佩服,因为他们经常面对的是保守的和木讷的
先生和官员。
还有两个互相紧密联系的因素不可忽视,一是他不忌张狂的自我评价,配以对流行意见
“错”、“亦错”这样干脆利落的断语。他正确地指出,经济学要解释世界的现象。但
是他宣称,真正可以做到解释现象的,全世界包括他自己在内,数起来也“只有四五个
人”。中国大陆许多从小在谨 | t**e 发帖数: 256 | 2 I believe if Cheung is studying economics now, he will still be a top one.
Much better than most of us.
Ask yourself if you can publish your dissertation by Chicago Press just afer
graduation. You even don't need ask yourself if you can get a position in
Chicago, if a Nobel Prize winner will express his thanks to you at the
ceremony. If you can do any of them, then you may be able to bash him.
But if you are at his level, you may not speak those stupid words like this
reporter.
三
【在 j*****x 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : 不是天才,不要学张五常 : ■文/王则柯 : 如果张五常先生曾经这样走过来了并且成就为大师的话,当今世界已经没有你邯郸学步 : 的机会了。首先,谁叫你比张五常先生晚了半个世纪呢。第二,却是更重要的,谁叫你 : 不是张五常先生那样的天才呢?我敢断言,缺了这两个条件,特别是天才条件,张五常 : 的路就走不通。要知道,我们只是不比别人笨的凡人。即使会比别人勤奋一些,但还是 : 凡人,不是张五常那样的天才。 : “张五常热”的合理性 : “张五常热”在中国的出现,有它的合理性。他的“佃农理论”,是深刻的研究,此其 : 一;科斯(RonaldCoase)这样的经济学大师,奉他为罕有的知音,此其二。还可以有三
| l*o 发帖数: 36 | 3 knowledge has no boundary, nor does people's stupidity. it is good to see
someone who managed to achieve both in one life while I have neither. but
guess it doesn't hinder my humble ability to speak about knowledge and
stupidity as two very different things. it doesn't need to take a nobel
prize winner to figure it out.
【在 t**e 的大作中提到】![](/moin_static193/solenoid/img/up.png) : I believe if Cheung is studying economics now, he will still be a top one. : Much better than most of us. : Ask yourself if you can publish your dissertation by Chicago Press just afer : graduation. You even don't need ask yourself if you can get a position in : Chicago, if a Nobel Prize winner will express his thanks to you at the : ceremony. If you can do any of them, then you may be able to bash him. : But if you are at his level, you may not speak those stupid words like this : reporter. : : 三
| t**e 发帖数: 256 | 4 Just find it
作者为中山大学岭南学院教授。本文系作者即将出版的文集《〈经济解释〉的困惑》
的前言,标题为编者所加. |
|