n*******r
发帖数: 618 | 1 一个reviewer的意见很多...要改很多结构
唉，英文的问题还是很多啊，一个reviewer直接说作者是不是chinese或者Russian
还以为自己written english不错呢，看来还得多写啊
不知道major revision再被录取可能性大么？ |
b*****d
发帖数: 61690 | |
n*******r
发帖数: 618 | 3 多谢多谢！！
【在 b*****d 的大作中提到】
: 照着该，只要该的好，是能发表的。
|
S***n
发帖数: 102 | 4 As both a reviewer and an author, I have seen many papers including my
students' with a recommendation for acceptance upon a major revision.
Therefore, it is not bad at all and you should be very happy with your very
first manuscript (maybe?). However, you should appreciate the time and
comments that the reviewers provided. So when you revise, be positive and
professional to the comments. Do whatever the reviewers suggested with
responses to comments one by one with an appreciative aptitude. Do |
n*******r
发帖数: 618 | 5 ahh thank you very much!!
This is my first manuscript....And this really helps! Thanks a lot for your
kind suggestions!! Hope I could get this published soon~~
Thank you!
very
rebut
If
【在 S***n 的大作中提到】
: As both a reviewer and an author, I have seen many papers including my
: students' with a recommendation for acceptance upon a major revision.
: Therefore, it is not bad at all and you should be very happy with your very
: first manuscript (maybe?). However, you should appreciate the time and
: comments that the reviewers provided. So when you revise, be positive and
: professional to the comments. Do whatever the reviewers suggested with
: responses to comments one by one with an appreciative aptitude. Do
|
a**********d
发帖数: 2293 | 6 看来各个领域这方面差异不小。我们这行儿R&R之后被据的例子听说过不少，我自己就
碰上过一次，本系一个同事第二次R&R后毙掉，气得要吐血。 |
w********6
发帖数: 12977 | 7 it is quite unusual and politically incorrect for the reviewer to suggest
the ethnicity of authors. You can criticize the English in the paper but not
suggest an stereotype.
Major revision is just another chance, I even know examples of paper being
accepted eventually after the initial rejection.
【在 n*******r 的大作中提到】
: 一个reviewer的意见很多...要改很多结构
: 唉，英文的问题还是很多啊，一个reviewer直接说作者是不是chinese或者Russian
: 还以为自己written english不错呢，看来还得多写啊
: 不知道major revision再被录取可能性大么？
|
w********6
发帖数: 12977 | 8 you apparently haven't seen enough. Most of the papers will be rejected
after major revisions, some never been resubmitted since the revision
requests are difficult to meet.
Of course, I am talking about top journals. |
w********6
发帖数: 12977 | 9 don't get personal, maybe it is otherwise in some fields. I just speak from
the perspective of business school. |
w********6
发帖数: 12977 | 10 then they are quite lucky :) |
|
|
p*u
发帖数: 8 | 11 This is true, at least for CELL. I was rejected two times after major revisions.
【在 w********6 的大作中提到】
: you apparently haven't seen enough. Most of the papers will be rejected
: after major revisions, some never been resubmitted since the revision
: requests are difficult to meet.
: Of course, I am talking about top journals.
|
j****s
发帖数: 156 | 12 这里见过。。。。
属于2个review ok一个不ok，最后硬是据了
不过楼主的这种情况还可以。好好改吧
con first |
n*******w
发帖数: 6708 | 13 那MINOR REVISION呢
我的文章MINOR REVISION,修改版投出去10天了，还是没信，
一般好像MINOR REVISION会最终接收的
怎么这次这么慢，很担心
主要有个地方回答作者的提问不是太好。 |
a*******g
发帖数: 39 | 14 major revision没问题的，只要你按着reviewer的意见都改了，能收的。 |
w********6
发帖数: 12977 | 15 10天？ 我知道某些变态的 journal 能拖一年。 minor 应该没问题了。
【在 n*******w 的大作中提到】
: 那MINOR REVISION呢
: 我的文章MINOR REVISION,修改版投出去10天了，还是没信，
: 一般好像MINOR REVISION会最终接收的
: 怎么这次这么慢，很担心
: 主要有个地方回答作者的提问不是太好。
|
f*****t
发帖数: 901 | 16 看什么journal吧。
【在 n*******r 的大作中提到】
: 一个reviewer的意见很多...要改很多结构
: 唉，英文的问题还是很多啊，一个reviewer直接说作者是不是chinese或者Russian
: 还以为自己written english不错呢，看来还得多写啊
: 不知道major revision再被录取可能性大么？
|
