l*******b
发帖数: 425 | 1 How do I know whether I was invited as a regular reviewer or adjudicative
reviewer ? Does second or third round review considered as adjudicative
review ? Can't type Chinese here. Thanks! |
l****u
发帖数: 3449 | 2 编辑在邀请信里会说，我们已经收到两个review意见相反，请你做adjudicator，判断一
下，然后把两个reviewer的意见发给你
你既然连这样的email都没见过，你就肯定不是，放心吧
【在 l*******b 的大作中提到】
: How do I know whether I was invited as a regular reviewer or adjudicative
: reviewer ? Does second or third round review considered as adjudicative
: review ? Can't type Chinese here. Thanks!
|
l*******b
发帖数: 425 | |
k******e
发帖数: 8870 | 4 u will notice if u r invited as an adjudicative reviewer. usually when the
previous reviewers have conflict comments about the manuscript or when the
author appeal the reviewers, the editor will need to consult an adjudicative
reviewer.
【在 l*******b 的大作中提到】
: How do I know whether I was invited as a regular reviewer or adjudicative
: reviewer ? Does second or third round review considered as adjudicative
: review ? Can't type Chinese here. Thanks!
|
y****c
发帖数: 2260 | 5 如果做过adjudicative reviewer，是不是也能狠狠吹上几句？ |
y****c
发帖数: 2260 | 6 翻了下，好像都没有做过adjudicative reviewer |
F****x
发帖数: 517 | 7 可以吹
【在 y****c 的大作中提到】
: 翻了下，好像都没有做过adjudicative reviewer
|
