n******h
发帖数: 2544 | 1 看起来，Vanguard完败啊，表现基本一样都是index，但是费率0.18%，高于Fidelity的
0.1%。岂不是和他们Bogle的低费率哲学相矛盾吗？
1 Year 3 Year 5 Year 10 Year
Vanguard 11.02% 9.61% 1.80% 6.88%
FSTMX 11.01 9.71 1.76 6.88 |
c*****e
发帖数: 1106 | 2 Well, firstly Fidelity funds offer low expense as well. Secondly, Vanguard
funds usually have more share classes, so it tends to divide
their customers into more categories and charge their best customers much
less and retail investors more. Overall expenses are still very low.
In this case,
Its InstlPls class VITPX has an unbeatable fee of 0.02%. |
t***n
发帖数: 546 | 3 FSTMX 最少要10k吧。为啥不跟VTSAX比？
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.7
【在 n******h 的大作中提到】
: 看起来，Vanguard完败啊，表现基本一样都是index，但是费率0.18%，高于Fidelity的
: 0.1%。岂不是和他们Bogle的低费率哲学相矛盾吗？
: 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year 10 Year
: Vanguard 11.02% 9.61% 1.80% 6.88%
: FSTMX 11.01 9.71 1.76 6.88
|
w***n
发帖数: 1519 | 4 vanguard 多的是便宜的指数基金，非要挑个贵的出来，不完败都难。
你要是有10000块钱可以买admiral shares 的vtsax，要是没几块钱的话总可以买etf的
vti吧？
好比你去dollar store，颇有一些确实便宜的东西，你非要指着其中一件卖得比
walmart 贵的东西说这和dollar store的口号矛盾，那是跟自己过不去，实在没意义。
同样的东西哪儿便宜你在哪买就是了 |
n******h
发帖数: 2544 | 5 why there is need for multiple etf total index fund?
I think there should be only one index fund for domestic total market, right?
【在 w***n 的大作中提到】
: vanguard 多的是便宜的指数基金，非要挑个贵的出来，不完败都难。
: 你要是有10000块钱可以买admiral shares 的vtsax，要是没几块钱的话总可以买etf的
: vti吧？
: 好比你去dollar store，颇有一些确实便宜的东西，你非要指着其中一件卖得比
: walmart 贵的东西说这和dollar store的口号矛盾，那是跟自己过不去，实在没意义。
: 同样的东西哪儿便宜你在哪买就是了
|
w***n
发帖数: 1519 | 6 For total domestic stock market, Vanguard only provides one etf as far as I
know: vti.
If you are talking about the need for multiple total index etf's in one's
portfolio, it depends on whether you have other brokerage accounts where it
makes sense to buy for example what ishares/schwab/spdr provides.
As for mutual funds, I assume you do know that vtsmx is not etf, right?
Vanguard provides several different classes for obvious reasons: they run at
different costs, why ask the customers with different position sizes to pay
the same?
right?
【在 n******h 的大作中提到】
: why there is need for multiple etf total index fund?
: I think there should be only one index fund for domestic total market, right?
|
j****n
发帖数: 4358 | 7 我买的fidelity 基金expense 普遍比vanguard 高
【在 n******h 的大作中提到】
: 看起来，Vanguard完败啊，表现基本一样都是index，但是费率0.18%，高于Fidelity的
: 0.1%。岂不是和他们Bogle的低费率哲学相矛盾吗？
: 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year 10 Year
: Vanguard 11.02% 9.61% 1.80% 6.88%
: FSTMX 11.01 9.71 1.76 6.88
|
