c****t
发帖数: 5452 | 1 Notes里说
Several analyses done by others convinced us that it was fair to
characterize Ye’s performance as ‘anomalous’ — in the sense that it was
statistically unusual. But we acknowledge that the combination of errors
discussed above and the absence of a more detailed discussion of the
statistics (which with hindsight we regret) gave the impression that we were
supporting accusations against her,
可能我理解有问题，这个意思是说他们有statistics去suspect吗？真想看看他们背后
的statistics analysis到底是什么，从最近这么多数据看，小叶估计不会被划为
unusual, 可惜人还是不写出来。 | M*****n
发帖数: 16729 | 2 this is a critical point,
from this notes, Nature is still insisting that Ye's performance is "
anomolous". However, from the statistical point of view, Ye's performance is
among a number of atheletes who also showed "anomolous"performance in this
Olympics, including the women's 800 freestyle gold medalist from US. Yet,
nobody is suspecting her doping.
The original paper is very bad, with wrong data, wrong analyses, and wrong
conlusion. It should be retracted.
was
were
【在 c****t 的大作中提到】
: Notes里说
: Several analyses done by others convinced us that it was fair to
: characterize Ye’s performance as ‘anomalous’ — in the sense that it was
: statistically unusual. But we acknowledge that the combination of errors
: discussed above and the absence of a more detailed discussion of the
: statistics (which with hindsight we regret) gave the impression that we were
: supporting accusations against her,
: 可能我理解有问题，这个意思是说他们有statistics去suspect吗？真想看看他们背后
: 的statistics analysis到底是什么，从最近这么多数据看，小叶估计不会被划为
: unusual, 可惜人还是不写出来。
| w********e
发帖数: 1416 | 3 不用在意这个，按对我们有利的解释，广泛传播，继续痛打。交了认罪书，该怎么解释
，就由不得他们了。 | d*****t
发帖数: 7903 | 4 你说得对，避重就轻，这些所谓analayses本身就是joke, 这些editors不严谨。
一定要他们为这个道歉。 | Q*****n
发帖数: 4546 | 5 问题是anormolous怎么定义，也可以说你列的这些都是；关键不能从anormolous就说吃
药了
is
this
【在 M*****n 的大作中提到】
: this is a critical point,
: from this notes, Nature is still insisting that Ye's performance is "
: anomolous". However, from the statistical point of view, Ye's performance is
: among a number of atheletes who also showed "anomolous"performance in this
: Olympics, including the women's 800 freestyle gold medalist from US. Yet,
: nobody is suspecting her doping.
: The original paper is very bad, with wrong data, wrong analyses, and wrong
: conlusion. It should be retracted.
:
: was
| r********y
发帖数: 25 | 6 Nature is just trying to save a bit face.
Don't think there would much more trouble for Ye.
There are much more "anormolous" out there under their nose. |
|
