s********e
发帖数: 893 | 1 比方说我找个水管工给我修东西，结果没修好还收费高。我气不过就找个网站post了他
的电话号码，然后把我的经历客观的叙述一下，没有任何攻击性语言。两个问题，第一
，我这么做有没有问题，个人有没有权利在网站上公布另一个人的电话号码。第二，如
果这个网站就是专门让人complain其他公司或个人的，这个网站的存在有没有问题。不
知道BBB是不是就是这个类型的。Angieslist有两个案例，两个顾客complain了一个公司，留了negative comment。这个公司sue了这两个顾客million $. 感觉在美国好像很容易就找个理由sue一个人。大家展开说说。谢了先。
以下引自wiki：
According to the Washington Post, two Angie's List members who submitted negative reviews about SCS Contracting Group to Angie's List have found themselves sued for libel by the contractor for millions of dollars in damages. One of the Angie's List members being sued put it this way, "If [contractors are] able to sue, then the value of Angie's List depreciates…People aren't going to be willing to submit reviews if they could be threatened with a lawsuit."[16] On 23 December 2009, the District of Columbia Courts dismissed all complaints against Defendants including Angie's List officers, various SCS customers, a Washington Post columnist and the District of Columbia after a two-year court case | s**********a
发帖数: 3273 | 2 I think your question is way beyond anybody's capability to
answer if you are getting serious. Even a lawyer wouldn't
be able to tell you until a real case has been set up and
solved in court.
Have you ever heard the saying? "This is the USA. Anybody
can sue anybody for whatever reason or no reason."
公司，留
了negative comment。这个公司sue了这两个顾客million $. 感觉在美国好像很容易就
找个理
由sue一个人。大家展开说说。谢了先。
submitted negative reviews about SCS Contracting Group to Angie's List
have found themselves sued for libel by the contractor for millions of
dollars in damages. One of the Angie's List members being sued put it
this way, "If [contractors are] able to sue, then the value of Angie's
List depreciates…People aren't going to be willing to submit reviews if
they could be threatened with a lawsuit."[16] On 23 December 2009, the
District : of Columbia Courts dismissed all complaints against
Defendants including Angie's List officers, various SCS customers, a
Washington Post columnist and the District of Columbia after a two-year
court case
【在 s********e 的大作中提到】
: 比方说我找个水管工给我修东西，结果没修好还收费高。我气不过就找个网站post了他
: 的电话号码，然后把我的经历客观的叙述一下，没有任何攻击性语言。两个问题，第一
: ，我这么做有没有问题，个人有没有权利在网站上公布另一个人的电话号码。第二，如
: 果这个网站就是专门让人complain其他公司或个人的，这个网站的存在有没有问题。不
: 知道BBB是不是就是这个类型的。Angieslist有两个案例，两个顾客complain了一个公司，留了negative comment。这个公司sue了这两个顾客million $. 感觉在美国好像很容易就找个理由sue一个人。大家展开说说。谢了先。
: 以下引自wiki：
: According to the Washington Post, two Angie's List members who submitted negative reviews about SCS Contracting Group to Angie's List have found themselves sued for libel by the contractor for millions of dollars in damages. One of the Angie's List members being sued put it this way, "If [contractors are] able to sue, then the value of Angie's List depreciates…People aren't going to be willing to submit reviews if they could be threatened with a lawsuit."[16] On 23 December 2009, the District of Columbia Courts dismissed all complaints against Defendants including Angie's List officers, various SCS customers, a Washington Post columnist and the District of Columbia after a two-year court case
| s********e
发帖数: 893 | 3 听楼上的意思就是现在没有一个明确的法律条文来断定我上面的两种说法到底是legal
还是illegal。当然，谁都可以sue别人。拿那个公司来说，它可以sue那两个留负评价
的人，也可以sue那个网站。那网站和那两个人你也可以反sue这个公司。但是sue归sue
，结果如何那就看各方律师谁牛了。 |
|
