a******m
发帖数: 1112 | 1 听说这篇Nature News很多早期的comments被删除了。
我随手保存了今天中午8/2/12的网页pdf，64页，Comments的编号
从47437开始，里面有包括JiangLai等几位的长篇comments。
我不知道怎么贴附件，如果有哪位需要的话，请联系我。
UPDATE:
对比了中午的存档和当前的nature网页，发现nature网站
设置的是显示299个最新的comments，只要有新的进来，
老的就看不到了。后来有很多人把Jiang Lai的长篇又贴了上去。
================
UPDATE: 08/03/12，
网页的文章有改动：
http://www.nature.com/news/why-great-olympic-feats-raise-suspic
Corrected: 03 August 2012
修正了小叶MM对比成绩的时间，加了editor's note，
但是不承认文中观点的偏见和结论的误导，更没有道歉的意思。
宣称不再接收comments，并且承认了选择性的删帖。
BTW，现在的网页存档有303个comments，而不是我们曾经认为... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
c*******n
发帖数: 43 | 3 Facebook Link (Sharing is welcomed and appreciated):
http://www.facebook.com/notes/hao-sun/worlds-acdemic-publishing
World's Acdemic Publishing Giant "No Longer Accepting" Comments and
Scientific Analysis on its Disturbing News Report
Aug. 3rd, 2012, 12:46pm EST|By chemrobin
Akron, OH(WSN)-"It is shame on Nature to publish such low quality article.
It only shows Nature is no longer one of top Journals." Andy Wu, one of the
numerous readers of a news report on the website of Nature, the world's
l... 阅读全帖 |
|
j******i
发帖数: 244 | 4 'Shamelessness profiling' could help to dispel uncertainties.
At the Olympics, trying how hard is hard enough? That question has dogged
British cyclist Philip Hindes after the 19-year-old won the three-lap race
against the French with his two teammates on Friday by crashing at the first
bend and securing a restart. In the aftermath of that race, Hindes
reportedly said that the strategy in the team sprint final was "if we have a
bad start, we need to crash to get a restart." However British Cycli... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
k*********t
发帖数: 2999 | 6 wow，这哥们学什么的？英语这么好！
first
a
predictably
declared |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
a****l
发帖数: 1696 | 14 这是一个重大的胜利。在我眼里，不亚于一块金牌。
总结：
1）感谢所有在网上留言还击的同胞，特别是那些用英文且能注意技巧的人。感谢饶毅
老师和他所引用的那几位华人的努力。他们的做法是榜样。他们告诉我们，还击不是为
了宣泄，而是为了在道义上打败对方，并争取在舆论上打败对方（这点目前很难，因为
我们没有话语权）
2）思考：为什么nature能出来反省？WSJ，CNN等就没这个压力呢？
http://www.nature.com/news/why-great-olympic-feats-raise-suspic
The story’s intention as an Explainer was to examine how science can help
resolve debates over extraordinary performances, not to examine those
performance statistics in detail. Several analyses done by others convinced
us that it was fair to ch... 阅读全帖 |
|
T*P
发帖数: 2697 | 15 cong.
这是一个重大的胜利。在我眼里，不亚于一块金牌。
总结：
1）感谢所有在网上留言还击的同胞，特别是那些用英文且能注意技巧的人。感谢饶毅
老师和他所引用的那几位华人的努力。他们的做法是榜样。他们告诉我们，还击不是为
了宣泄，而是为了在道义上打败对方，并争取在舆论上打败对方（这点目前很难，因为
我们没有话语权）
2）思考：为什么nature能出来反省？WSJ，CNN等就没这个压力呢？
http://www.nature.com/news/why-great-olympic-feats-raise-suspic
The story’s intention as an Explainer was to examine how science can help
resolve debates over extraordinary performances, not to examine those
performance statistics in detail. Several analyses done by others convinced
us that it was fai... 阅读全帖 |
|
L*****y
发帖数: 4290 | 16 这次牛就牛在不光在bbs上抱怨, 大家真的行动起来了
这是一个重大的胜利。在我眼里，不亚于一块金牌。
总结：
1）感谢所有在网上留言还击的同胞，特别是那些用英文且能注意技巧的人。感谢饶毅
老师和他所引用的那几位华人的努力。他们的做法是榜样。他们告诉我们，还击不是为
了宣泄，而是为了在道义上打败对方，并争取在舆论上打败对方（这点目前很难，因为
我们没有话语权）
2）思考：为什么nature能出来反省？WSJ，CNN等就没这个压力呢？
http://www.nature.com/news/why-great-olympic-feats-raise-suspic
The story’s intention as an Explainer was to examine how science can help
resolve debates over extraordinary performances, not to examine those
performance statistics in detail. Several analyses done by others convinc... 阅读全帖 |
|
d**o
发帖数: 864 | 17 写了一简短的草稿,我文笔不好,请大家补充吧,结稿可将此事在人人微博上广为传播.
有些证据我没保留下来,还请有存档的人补充.
如Nature原文,原Editor's Notes
---------------------------------------
事起Nature的编辑Ewen Callaway在8月1号发了一篇有偏见的news article,Why great
Olympic feats raise suspicions--'Performance profiling' could help to catch
cheaters[附1],暗示叶诗文服禁药.
此文被Mitbbs上的Biology版的WSN们首先发现,引起众怒,纷纷上去评论反对此文观点,
其中不乏用科学的方法从头到尾反驳此报道,特别是Lai Jiang的评论获得广泛支持[附2
].刚开始Nature的Editor们还嘴硬,并且Senior Editor, Noah Gray在twitter上嘲笑发
表评论的人[附3].
于此同时,WSN们纷纷致信Editor in Chief, Philip Campbell.可... 阅读全帖 |
|
c***t
发帖数: 324 | 18 http://www.nature.com/news/why-great-olympic-feats-raise-suspic
Lai Jiang写得真全面真给力，我唯一能想到的可能可以加上的是(我英语不好）：
Seventh and most importantly, Olympic games is the foremost sports
competition, billions of people enjoy watching the games and being excited
and inspired, true talents like Ye Shiwen and Missy Franklin etc. and even
more so, Michael Phelps and Usain Bolt etc. greatly added to the merit of
games. It is a shame if the general public have to be misled to always think
"he/she must be doping" wh... 阅读全帖 |
|
a********x
发帖数: 1502 | 19 Big Data Analysis of Swimming Athletes' Performance Records
http://www.ittc.ku.edu/huanlab/sensorData/
In the August issue Nature published a news article titled "Why great
Olympic feats raise suspicions". In the article Mr. Callaway questioned the
record-breaking performance of the 2012 London Olympic gold medal winner Ye
Shiwen.
We believe that data should provide knowledge about the accused "anomalous"
performance. We agree with Callaway that databases should be constructed to
record how athl... 阅读全帖 |
|
W**********n
发帖数: 187 | 20 (CNN) -- Famed cyclist Lance Armstrong faces the prospect of losing seven
Tour de France titles and his fabled championship legacy after he ended his
fight against charges of illegal doping.
Armstrong, who has consistently denied allegations of illegal doping, made
his announcement to stop battling the U.S. Anti-Doping Agency's "one-sided
and unfair process" move against him after losing a legal bid Monday to stop
the probe.
The cyclist's decision prompted the anti-doping agency to say it will s... 阅读全帖 |
|
m**c
发帖数: 7349 | 21 Athletics can ill afford, at a point when public trust in its integrity has
ebbed away to an alarming degree, to wait too long for another saviour.
It is futile even pretending, though, that anybody with Bolt’s
transcendence will emerge for a generation or more. His ‘triple-triple’ of
Olympic sprint titles – nine finals, nine gold medals – stands as a feat
for the ages.
So, too, does his set of world records.
In looking for the next wave, there is no more logical place to start than
his Jamaican... 阅读全帖 |
|
g********d
发帖数: 4174 | 22 http://finance.yahoo.com/career-work/article/111858/best-compan
Best Companies to Work For, 2011
Thursday, January 20, 2011FortuneonCNNMoney.com
SAS takes the prize again! When it comes to workplaces, few companies offer
the kinds of perks the privately held software giant does: Employees at its
Cary, N.C., campus can help themselves to everything from a tailor, a
manicurist, and a hair salon, to summer camp programs for kids, to car
detailing — all of which helped land the company at the to... 阅读全帖 |
|
m******1
发帖数: 19713 | 23 Bob Barr早就表态过反对DOMA
Bob Barr on DOMA
Rep. Bob Barr, the author of the Defense of Marriage Act, speaks to The
Advocate on his about-face on the law, the Republicans’ continued defense
of it, and the Obama administration’s pledge to continue enforcing it.
By Andrew Harmon
BOB BARR X390 (GETTY IMAGES) | ADVOCATE.COM
Rep. Bob Barr, the four-term Republican congressman from Georgia, the
Libertarian Party’s 2008 presidential candidate, and the author of the 1996
Defense of Marriage Act, no longer supp... 阅读全帖 |
|
k*****e
发帖数: 22013 | 24 我查了一下名单，应该不是内容的问题，绝大多数歌曲都是恩恩爱爱的情歌。
不过这种歌曲内容审查制度的存在，本身合理性就成问题。
附件：
第三批未经内容审查或备案的网络音乐产品名单
歌曲名 歌手名 唱片公司
自然醒 林宥嘉 华研国际
晚安 林宥嘉 华研国际
纪念品 林宥嘉 华研国际
RUN THE WORLD(GIRLS) 碧昂斯 诺里斯 索尼音乐
昙花 方大同 华纳唱片
情胜策略 方大同 华纳唱片
无菇朋友 方大同 华纳唱片
一百万种亲吻 梁文音 环球音乐
姐妹淘 梁文音 环球音乐
我最亲爱的 张惠妹 金牌大风
你在看我吗 张惠妹 金牌大风
还有眼泪就好 张惠妹 金牌大风
Honey And The Bee Owl City 环球唱片
The Real World Owl City 环球唱片
Plant Life Owl City 环球唱片
You Suck At Love Simple Plan... 阅读全帖 |
|
g********d
发帖数: 4174 | 25 Posted on Advocate.com October 13, 2011 06:26:40 PM ET
Poll Has Bad News for North Carolina, But Not All Bad
By Lucas Grindley
A new poll shows both a setback and an opportunity for opponents of a
marriage ban proposed in North Carolina.
Public Policy Polling found that 61% of North Carolinians now support the
antigay amendment to the state's constitution. The poll contradicted one
from Elon University in late September that showed only 39% support.
The Elon poll had spread optimism among the r... 阅读全帖 |
|
m******8
发帖数: 2153 | 26 原来照片还是有出处的
http://www.pinknews.co.uk/2011/11/17/benetton-withdraws-ad-feat
Italian clothing brand Benetton has withdrawn a manipulated image of the
pope kissing another man from its newly unveiled Unhate campaign after the
Vatican protested.
The altered image depicted the Pope Benedict XVI locked in a clinch with
Sheik Ahmed Muhammaed el-Tayeb, a leading Egyptian theologian and Imam of
the 1000-year-old Al-Azhar Mosque.
The Vatican said: “This shows a grave lack of respect for the Pope, an
offen... 阅读全帖 |
|
D**S
发帖数: 24887 | 27 Bravo!
Republicans in New England traditionally tend to be more tolerant on social
issues. But yeah, it is still quite a feat for all of the five to vote yes. |
|
D**S
发帖数: 24887 | 28 You mean the hike between the two rims of the Grand Canyon? Wow! I can only
dream that one day I can, too, accomplish such a feat. |
|
|
k*****u
发帖数: 14053 | 30 才看见！ 赞！
authkey=Gv1sRgCPfSuoWV4IicDA&feat=directlink#5603461850234176802 |
|
|
|
g*********s
发帖数: 280 | 33 [This is an interesting and informative news article. You can easily find
that most arguments remain true if you change India in the article to China.
]
By NIDA NAJAR, New York Times, October 13 2011
NEW DELHI — Moulshri Mohan was an excellent student at one of the top
private high schools in New Delhi. When she applied to colleges, she
received scholarship offers of $20,000 from Dartmouth and $15,000 from Smith
. Her pile of acceptance letters would have made any ambitious teenager
smile: Corn... 阅读全帖 |
|
l****z
发帖数: 29846 | 34 Forget 'clean energy.' Oil and gas are boosting U.S. employment.
o President Obama was right all along. Domestic energy production really is
a path to prosperity and new job creation. His mistake was predicting that
those new jobs would be "green," when the real employment boom is taking
place in oil and gas.
The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported recently that the U.S. jobless rate
remains a dreadful 9%. But look more closely at the data and you can see
which industries are bucking the jobless... 阅读全帖 |
|
l****z
发帖数: 29846 | 35 巴马带来的改变：“只有在今天的华盛顿，才有总统绕过自己宣称的不许雇用游说人的
禁令，雇用游说公司的老板”
By Dana Milbank, Published: March 6
Three years into his presidency, Barack Obama has finally overcome his pesky
, puritanical aversion to K Street.
As a candidate, Obama pledged that lobbyists “will not run my White House.
” But on Monday, the president brought in one of this town’s most
prominent lobbyists to run his White House — or at least a nice piece of it.
Ricchetti achieved this feat — getting around the ban on lobbyists serving
in... 阅读全帖 |
|
l******a
发帖数: 3803 | 36 Watching RNC, all white/pink faces, kind of weird, and some are below-
looking.
Then, DNC comes along. Wow, you have to wonder where they rounded up these
people???
I know, they want to make themselves look desirable on entitlement - they
nailed it, this time.
Weird is nobody talking about where to fund their expensive costly dreams??!
! Do we miss something here?
Jesse is here as well. He repeatedly refer to a guy president Barack.
A feat of Vampires, bravo!
One more thing: you get all kinds of... 阅读全帖 |
|
B*****e
发帖数: 9375 | 37 Yes, 他就是个性情中人.
讲个八卦, 2000年大选前, 因为正值棒球的最后总冠军决赛,
于是有家新闻社就顺水推舟, 问了Bush/Gore同样一个问题:
"What do you think of domed stadiums?"
很不痛不痒, 很好回答的一个问题, 结果,
Gore的回答全文如下:
"The design and construction of domed stadiums - in Seattle (the Kingdome
was the first free-standing current dome ever built), Houston (the Astrodome
was the first stadium to use astroturf) and Minnesota (the Metrodome is the
only stadium in the USA whose roof is suspended without beams or rods - it'
s supported by air pressure), for example ... 阅读全帖 |
|
G*******1
发帖数: 6411 | 38 越来越多的美国人对未来担忧
http://news.yahoo.com/blogs/ticket/world-2030-u-declines-food-w
orry, everyone, but flying cars don't appear in the "Global Trends 2030:
Alternative Worlds" report that the director of national intelligence's
office made public on Monday.
Instead, the National Intelligence Council paints the picture of a world in
which the U.S. is no longer the unquestionably dominant global player;
individuals and small groups may carry out devastating cyber or bioterror
attacks; oh, and food and ... 阅读全帖 |
|
l****z
发帖数: 29846 | 39 By Stuart J. Moskovitz
John Kerry always believed he was qualified to be President of the United
States. While I grant he certainly had a far better résumé than the
current office holder, there was little in that résumé to instill
confidence in any careful observer that he had the courage, the integrity,
the character to occupy this lofty perch. The lack of these three elements
are evident in the current president and we are all suffering the
consequences.
Our introduction to John Kerry came wit... 阅读全帖 |
|
l****z
发帖数: 29846 | 40 In that dreary winter of 1979, the piles of uncollected trash in London's
Finsbury Park seemed to stretch for miles. The garbagemen were on strike. So
too, at one time or another, were hospital workers, ambulance drivers,
truck drivers, railwaymen. Also gravediggers: In Liverpool, corpses had to
be warehoused as they awaited burial—yet another long queue that socialist
Britain had arranged for its patient masses.
This was the "Winter of Discontent," when Great Britain came about as close
to econ... 阅读全帖 |
|
m********a
发帖数: 1041 | 41 這個好棒! 堅持做對的事。
聯想起不久前芝加哥教師工會的罷工。
All this was done despite sharp short-term economic shocks and in the teeth
of immense resistance, particularly from trade unions. In 1984, the coal
miners union of Arthur Scargill went on strike for nearly a year. Similar
strikes had brought past governments to their knees, but Thatcher, in a feat
of immense courage and political skill, remained immovable and eventually
won public opinion to her side. As she had famously said of herself a few
years earlier (with... 阅读全帖 |
|
l****z
发帖数: 29846 | 42 当时她可是储备了一年半的英国煤的消耗量. 结果工会支持了快一年吧,终于顶不住了.
teeth
feat |
|
c*****g
发帖数: 21627 | 43 Michael Lewis: Did Goldman Sachs Overstep in Criminally Charging Its Ex-
Programmer?
A month after ace programmer Sergey Aleynikov left Goldman Sachs, he was
arrested. Exactly what he’d done neither the F.B.I., which interrogated him
, nor the jury, which convicted him a year later, seemed to understand. But
Goldman had accused him of stealing computer code, and the 41-year-old
father of three was sentenced to eight years in federal prison.
Investigating Aleynikov’s case, Michael Lewis holds a s... 阅读全帖 |
|
l****z
发帖数: 29846 | 44 Even Vacation Doesn’t Prevent Obama From Begging for Money
by Jammie
It just never stops. From the mailbox:
Jammie –
They said it couldn’t be done.
When our first Presidential campaign began, the naysayers dismissed the
chances of a grassroots campaign powered by everyday folks organizing in
their communities. Together, we proved them wrong.
Now those same critics claim we will fall short of regaining a
Democratic House for the final two years of my term. But once again, you’re... 阅读全帖 |
|
l****z
发帖数: 29846 | 45 The Brian Williams scandal is an NBC News-wide scandal
The Brian Williams scandal has burst onto the public square through a feat
of Internet accountability.
After NBC Nightly News last week posted to Facebook a clip of the anchor
reminiscing about having embedded with the U.S. invasion of Iraq in 2003,
some Facebookers took issue with the particulars. Whereas Williams claimed
that he was riding in a helicopter that was forced down after being hit by
an RPG, others had a different recollection. ... 阅读全帖 |
|
l****z
发帖数: 29846 | 46 Sanitizing Higher Education
By Robert Weissberg
The intellectual damage caused by forcing the university to admit
academically ill-prepared minority students is seemingly endless, but just
when it seems that matters cannot get any worse, they do.
The latest installment of this crusade now occurs at the University of
Illinois-Urbana, a school where I taught political science for 28 years, so
I know this nonsense first hand. Here’s the sorrowful tale (for a Harvard
version, see here).
According t... 阅读全帖 |
|
i***a
发帖数: 4718 | 47 http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/20/us/politics/donald-trump-camp
Translating a personality-driven campaign to the voting booth is no easy
feat, especially for a candidate who has never run before.
Mr. Trump’s Iowa director predicted that he would recruit a leader for each
of the state’s 1,681 Republican precincts by Thanksgiving. Instead, the
first major training session for precinct leaders, heavily promoted in
emails and conference calls, drew only about 80 people to West Des Moines
last weeken... 阅读全帖 |
|
l****z
发帖数: 29846 | 48 All-Out ‘Equality’ in the Military Is an Ideological Fallacy
By Hannah Wegman | February 10, 2016 | 2:40 PM EST
The GOP candidates were prepared for anything the moderators might throw at
them at last week’s debate in New Hampshire. From immigration to what
toppings Megyn Kelly likes on her pizza, they were ready. But when asked
about whether they agree with instituting a female-integrated draft, they
started to squirm. The question arises since, in 2015, the Defense
Department officially extend... 阅读全帖 |
|
T*********I
发帖数: 10729 | 49 Political correctness is destroying America, and Western civilization.
This year America celebrates her 240th birthday. If she is to make her tri-
centennial in 2076, a feat few great nations in history have achieved, it
will need to crush this totalitarian ideology that is currently strangling
it.
Every problem in America today is linked to political correctness. Declining
educational standards, increasing secularism, the police not being allowed
to do their job, an inability to secure her bord... 阅读全帖 |
|
n******1
发帖数: 3756 | 50 我早说他不会直接endorse Trump
Dr.Ben Carson:
I have lived a blessed life and achieved more success than I ever dreamed
was possible. Running for President was never on my bucket list, and when I
was drafted by a grassroots movement asking me to do so, it was not a
decision that I made lightly and saw as an act of service.
However, I believed that my values, life experience and common sense
solutions put me in a position to help get our nation back on track for the
sake of our children and grandchildren.... 阅读全帖 |
|
