d**********i
发帖数: 365 | 1 这个球判罚的是重发（let），原因可能是边线裁判没看清楚球且主裁判无法判断。
14.2.6 a line judge is unsighted and the umpire is unable to make a decision;
注意到边裁说了句“i didnt see it"，说明边裁没看清楚。但注意，这个是判罚发球
，不是判罚出界与否。所以14.2.6这条在这里不适用。
另外一种判罚let是双方同时fault，然而，在录像中我并没有看到发球裁判说任何一方
发球接发球fault。
球挂网了吗？球解体了？或者有突发事件？有球员受干扰了？都没有！！于是，这个
let的判罚显然说明该裁判做出了一个错误的判罚。
这球正确的判罚只可能是判罚大马队得分。不好说陈文宏是否是故意这样的，但即使是
故意的，规则上也没有说不准故意这样发，即应该是point of law。
可以再做个假设，假如这个判罚是正确的，那么只要对方发离中线近的平射球，接发者
无法接着，接发者的同伴用手一抓，就可以重发了，就避免失分了....... |
|
l*********y
发帖数: 3447 | 2 版三真是见多识广呀，这都能找出来。
这是裁判的失误，怎么能嚷嚷line judge呢？line judge很professional,球没落地，
不管多么明显，说I did not see it是正确的。发球裁判没啃声，所以肯定不过腰，不
过手。
最后，陈也未必是故意的，也许想发个平射球结果发歪了，结果对方居然很没经验的用
手去接，自然是陈得分，陈找referee也是很正确的作法，居然被给了黄牌。。。
这个场景应该成为umpire training的经典scenario. |
|
A**d
发帖数: 13310 | 3 Bradley injured by the umpire&manager |
|
B*****t
发帖数: 3012 | 4 seems the umpire is generous on the lower half of the strike zone but
pretty tight up |
|
t*a
发帖数: 18880 | 5 I will say out.
maybe umpire thinks LaPorta reaches base first... (I don't think so) |
|
k***n
发帖数: 3158 | 6 after the first collision, we hit them once,
then they made the second collision, and our manager was ejected.
This means that they were still trying to hurt us, and we could not
get protection from the umpire. What could we do to protect us?
If we did not do some additional damage (hitting them on their fat asses
had been proved useless), it was highly possible they would run over our
players again. I think drilling him on head was very good, at least a
very effective way to protect our players |
|
t********t
发帖数: 5415 | 7 They threw at him five times, hitting him only twice.
......LOL
When home plate umpire Tim McClelland went looking
for another potential Rays manager to eject, he asked third base coach Billy
Hatcher who was in charge. "I don't know," said Hatcher, neglecting to
mention that he was.
......LOL again |
|
n*******e
发帖数: 2213 | 8
这种ball和strike从电视上很难看出来。摄像机不是直上直下的，看的有角度偏差。而
且ball/strike这个东西有个人因素在里面，很多时候我们只能看到自己想看的东西。
我觉得裁判还行。不过Home plate umpire今天又两个很明显的误判，那个strikeout t
o walk 很滑稽。Rollins那个HBP还情有可原。 |
|
A**d
发帖数: 13310 | 9 where are these crappy umpires from? game deciding errors
in every single game. |
|
n*******e
发帖数: 2213 | 10 我也不认为这个series的裁判很好。但是人总有失误的时候，而且不是所有的call都是
against rays。比方说，Rollins的HBP，那个K-BB against Myers，更不用说那个blow
n call against the brilliant play by Moyer at 1st which cost Phillies two ru
ns.
Human makes mistakes. I do it every day. As long as it is not intentional, i
t's not fair to blame the one who tries his best and still makes mistakes.
All the umpiring errors in the Series just cry two words :" instant replay".
This is it. |
|
A**d
发帖数: 13310 | 11 I just don't believe these umpires can performe so consistently poor.
blow
ru
i
". |
|
A**d
发帖数: 13310 | 12 good job homeplate umpire |
|
A**d
发帖数: 13310 | 13 The problem is Hamels always got favored calls by the same umpire,
at the same locations. Dude, keep pretending to be blind.
to
About |
|
B*****t
发帖数: 3012 | 14 actually should be safe
but umpire just got awed |
|
A**d
发帖数: 13310 | 15 With the consistent help of umpires, even a pile of shit like this
team could win the title. |
|
B*****t
发帖数: 3012 | 16 沒法調整，這strike zone一會是左邊特大一會是右邊特大。。。
不過仔細研究了一下，好像是很consistent的外角特大。。。
這home plate umpire應該去查查視力了，是不是有斜視啥的。
把贾 |
|
n*****g
发帖数: 274 | 17 话说回来，home plate umpire对比赛的影响也非常大。
好像大家抱怨的不多。 |
|
j*****n
发帖数: 3617 | 18 碰到有些free swinger，像pablo sandoval，有没有umpire对他关系不大。 |
|
G******f
发帖数: 16223 | 19 the second time to fool the umpire with a ball bounced from the wall/fence
already. lol |
|
B*****t
发帖数: 3012 | 20 估计umpire会不屑的说，有没有干扰结果都一样。。。
Varitek想了想就不自取其辱了。 |
|
G******f
发帖数: 16223 | 21 and he could have actually got a strike out looking, but the umpire didn't
give him. (the amica strike zone showed it's a strike) |
|
a*****i
发帖数: 4391 | 22 Buster Olney Blog:
Cracks in the AL contenders
Thursday, September 17, 2009 | Feedback | Print Entry
The count was full, the bases were loaded and Brian Fuentes fired a fastball
at the lowest part of the strike zone Wednesday night, and when home plate
umpire Rick Reed called the pitch a ball -- the K Zone indicated that
Fuentes' fastball nicked the strike zone -- and the tying run walked home,
Angels manager Mike Scioscia was incredulous. His lower jaw may or may not
have bounced off the dugout |
|
|
|
|
G******f
发帖数: 16223 | 26 这个一垒裁判明天suppose是home umpire. |
|
|
m*****a
发帖数: 266 | 28 TB把redsucks干掉，就没怎么看现场。呵呵
真有这回事啊，太过分了。那umpire还能接着执法？ |
|
w*********y
发帖数: 590 | 29 其实最后两局的strike zone都宽
It's reasonable that the umpire gave Garza the benefit of the doubt under
that circumstance |
|
n*******e
发帖数: 2213 | 30 Phillies are digging themselves a hole because they are lack of offense.
Without scoring runs, Phillies cannot win. But the umpires are not helping
the matter either. This is not as bad as the Braves/Giants series, but
Giants are getting a lot of calls.
So this more and more looks like a Giants/Rangers series. Good luck Giants!
bad |
|
A*****8
发帖数: 8590 | 31 http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870433040457629106
Chris Snyder is chasing one of baseball's oldest records, although "chasing"
might not be the best description. Let's try that again: Chris Snyder, a
catcher with the Pittsburgh Pirates, is lumbering his way toward baseball
infamy—he has never stolen a base.
With 2,094 trips to the plate spanning eight-major league seasons, Snyder
ranks fourth all-time for most career plate appearances without a stolen
base, according to Stats Inc. ... 阅读全帖 |
|
n*******e
发帖数: 2213 | 32 why in the world did the umpire stand in the infield? |
|
J*C
发帖数: 4579 | 33
棒球術語代碼
術語/ 英文/ 中文解釋
A/assists/助 殺
AB/at bats/打 數
AL/American League /美國聯盟
1B/first baseman/一壘手 / 一壘安打
2B/second baseman/二壘手 / 二壘安打
3B /third baseman/三壘手 / 三壘安打
B/balls/壞球數
BA/batting average/打擊率
BB/bases on balls/四壞球
BF/batters faced/投球人次
BFS/batters faced per start/投手過勞指數
BK/Balks/投手犯規數
BS /blown saves /救援失敗
C/catcher/ 捕手
CF/center fielder/中外野手
CG/complete games/完投場次
CS/ caught stealing/盜壘失敗
DH/designated hitter/指定打擊
DL/disabled list/受傷名單
DP /double plays/雙殺
E/errors/失誤
ER/earned runs/投手責任失分
E... 阅读全帖 |
|
i*********r
发帖数: 5101 | 34 well, Yankees got 5 runs from him. CC pitched OK, the umpire squeezed the
strike zone a little too much, Verlander pitched OK too, none of them was
great. |
|
n*******e
发帖数: 2213 | 35 you know what I am thinking? I just hope MLB orders the plate umpire to let
the big market team win. :p
oh well...pretty low, am not I? |
|
A**d
发帖数: 13310 | 36 you mean 4 stolen runs plus Harrison's good outing getting shorten
by those garbage umpires? |
|
A**d
发帖数: 13310 | 37 dude, you are not a new baseball fan, aren't you? If it was 2 out,
there was no way Molina was IBB, and Napoli wouldn't try to force out
at all. Napoli could simply WALKED back to 1B to get the 3rd out.
More importantly, Harrison would be 3H, 0B over 3.2 innings, very
decent numbers. All those crappy homers Pujols hit were direct outcome
of his hometown umpire buddy. |
|
c***s
发帖数: 4895 | 38 最后一句没看懂，HR关umpire屁事，如果你说的是原本2-0的坏球被搞成1-1好球，然后
Pujols被刺激了。。。 |
|
k***n
发帖数: 3158 | 39 anyway, that joke umpire got it back for the rangers tonight
guess he felt redeemed now, lol |
|
A**d
发帖数: 13310 | 40 ft. One 35-40 pitch inning taxes a pitcher much more than 2 20pitch innings
combined. With such a heavy load on Harrison, considering he's a young
pitcher
without rubber arm and still mad at the obvious blown call, there's nothing
wrong for Washington to pull him out. The umpire took Harrison out of the
ballgame.
MLB and Fox so desperately want to have game 6, so that Pujols non-last
game in St. Louis can draw good ratings.
Harrison |
|
k***n
发帖数: 3158 | 41 yeah, tighers are laughing their asses off
any pitcher can have CY performance if the umpire is on your side |
|
A**d
发帖数: 13310 | 42 Are you suggesting Mr. Wild Jackson would have walked 15 if the umpire
didn't have such a big strike zone? |
|
s****r
发帖数: 5546 | 43 Mr. fucked-by-umpire Harrison |
|
A**d
发帖数: 13310 | 44 I think it's actually harder to get PG when your own team has a big lead.
Teammates and fans would complain why you keep nibbling with a 10run lead.
Umpire would also be declined to give you favorable ball/strike calls. |
|
o******s
发帖数: 416 | 45 interference call was a good one.
infield fly rule call was a tough one, personally I think it was a really
bad judgement. The umpire can backup himself with the grey area of the rule,
but considering the overall situation at that moment and the intention of
infield fly rule, he should've just let the ball dropped without saying a
damn thing. |
|
A**d
发帖数: 13310 | 46 Ss don't often run so deep into outfield for a reason: making a backhand
catch is hard even for MLB players. And SS don't catch as many flyballs as
outfielders. The best excuse I can make for that garbage umpire is he was so
lazy that as soon as Kozma called, he just assumed an easy catch and didn't
bother to watch. |
|
t*****l
发帖数: 241 | 47 3rd base umpire also called infield fly at the same time. The call is not as
bad as braves fans yelled. Nobody can guarantee he/she could handle that
situation better. |
|
|
|
|
