|
s********t
发帖数: 4150 | 2 I concur that CISE reviewers tend to be quite reluctant to give "excellent"
ratings.
It is certainly true across the board that "good" means "not good". Funny,
huh :(
However
excellent"
that |
|
d**********6
发帖数: 74 | 3 Thanks! Hope so.
Proposal Status
Status As of Today Dated: 08/16/09
A program recommendation for award was concurred with by the cognizant
Division/Directorate on 08/07/09. However, no award is ensured and the
recommended duration is 12 months with an effective date of 09/01/09 are
subject to change. The grantee institution assumes any pre-award costs at
its own risk. NSF may request additional information.
Award Duration: (months)
This recommendation was received in the Division of Grants and A |
|
|
|
o**********n
发帖数: 125 | 6 I concur...
Eval
they
using
had |
|
o****y
发帖数: 790 | 7 With misty eyes, I concur.
At least Guozi should write something about this; I felt we deserve at
least that much... |
|
|
|
|
|
a**********e
发帖数: 67 | 12 I concur here. My LD and I have been long distance for sometime. It is
very difficult, but it can work out. There should be a plan in place to
get together though. LZ mentioned she gave up another Ivy offer. If the
current university is in a big city, it's well worth it because it makes
things much easier. |
|
|
|
o****y
发帖数: 790 | 15 I concur. Especially the 3rd line. |
|
o****y
发帖数: 790 | 16 Whew!
I concur.
BTW, I forgot to mention, my mantra is:It is good to dream, but it is better
to dream and work. Faith is mighty, but faith with action is mighter.
Adiou 5th.:) |
|
|
g*******t
发帖数: 1039 | 18 totally aglee (or "I concur" as some id would say :)) - though your reply as
is sounds too graduate-student-ish, not professor-ish
no biggie. so "No need to explain or apologize" is right in general, but
based on who he/she is, and who you are, some face to face dialog may help |
|
o****y
发帖数: 790 | 19 I concur.
Academic job is never meant for a faint of heart, which is not to say industry job is. |
|
o****y
发帖数: 790 | 20 I concur.
IVF well deserved it. Graphene film is big, but dubious to be nobel worthy.
Although I am not well-versed enough in physics to make such a call:)
Obama's Nobel is a joke. In general, trusting politician's words instead
of their actions is an insult to human intelligence. See, I am quite cynical:)
，直接就把石墨烯
懂了。 |
|
o****y
发帖数: 790 | 21 I concur.
I would rather award Obama with the Nobel literature. |
|
|
v****x
发帖数: 980 | 23 1.加入committee，不管是如何不情愿进去的，答应了就obligated要做事情，这个是你
的问题。
2.系头同意你回去，没有书面证据，你虽然没错，但是系头牵头fire你，估计她自己不
会承认，你跟工会说说看是不是能不能站在你这边吧。
3.没必要揪着细节了，估计这一年系里有人，或多人，不满意你。这些都是小事，只是
想fire你的借口。注意以后要professional一些。
4.我要是你就吸取教训换地方了。你一个人告系里"the senior faculty", 还有系主任concur，就是拖延时间，绝对解决不了问题。
fire |
|
w****y
发帖数: 2501 | 24 ta肯定要走的了，但一定要fight for rights
concur，就是拖延时间，绝对解决不了问题。 |
|
a**********d
发帖数: 2293 | 25 Re
任concur，就是拖延时间，绝对解
决不了问题。 |
|
b*********r
发帖数: 39 | 26 If LZ talked about an American guy, I concur with 20%.
For internationals (especially MALE Chinese), it is a day dream to nail a
decent faculty position and secure a tenure with only 20% academic caliber.
Obviously, LZ lacks in deep understanding the academia. |
|
h*****n
发帖数: 924 | 27 if it is such a huge mistake and others did not find it, you should really t
hink about whether you should find it. clearly, if you are right, you will s
how that they are all careless, irresponsible, and lousy. if you are wrong,
you will become a joke in their eyes.
the editor will also feel this letter to be thorny. few editors like this.
(obviously, not an appealing thing to deal with)
moreover, if this is an overt mistake and you correct it, you will get littl
e credit. it is not like provin... 阅读全帖 |
|
h*****n
发帖数: 924 | 28 if it is such a huge mistake and others did not find it, you should really t
hink about whether you should find it. clearly, if you are right, you will s
how that they are all careless, irresponsible, and lousy. if you are wrong,
you will become a joke in their eyes.
the editor will also feel this letter to be thorny. few editors like this.
(obviously, not an appealing thing to deal with)
moreover, if this is an overt mistake and you correct it, you will get littl
e credit. it is not like provin... 阅读全帖 |
|
l*******s
发帖数: 3562 | 29 concur this
不过这年头，竞争越来越激烈了
我们找个非Tenure Track的位置，居然最后面试的都是tenure track的AP |
|
L*****C
发帖数: 157 | 30 I concur. It is most likely a good news. |
|
p*******7
发帖数: 322 | 31 status变成了council review completed。今天给PO打电话了，她说council
concurred it，但现在还不知道funding,要等budget下来才能定，说话语气杠杠的。 |
|
|
s***r
发帖数: 238 | 33 I concur.
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.8 |
|
s***r
发帖数: 238 | 34 I concur.
★ 发自iPhone App: ChineseWeb 7.8 |
|
w*********g
发帖数: 813 | 35 终于回了,如下,我该怎么回?
Unfortunately, I was not part of the review process. After discussing this
with the managing editor. We concur that based on the reasons below, we
cannot accept this paper for publication.
With apologizes for any inconvenience, |
|
w*********g
发帖数: 813 | 36 他的reason 就是"Although the paper presents a solid study, the topic is much
too narrow and there is
no new science or insights elucidated".
没有新的comments. 就是本来7月份接受的稿子,10月份要发了之前,这个senior editor
给了如上comments,还说After discussing this with the managing editor. We
concur that based on the reasons below, we cannot accept this paper for
publication.同时copy了其它几个managing editors. |
|
f*******h
发帖数: 1269 | 37 OVERVIEW OF THE PROPOSAL:
INTELLECTUAL MERIT:
+ Strengths
- Weaknesses
* Potentially transformative?
BROADER IMPACTS:
* Impacts on science and society:
* Integration of Research and Education and Broadening Participation:
* Postdoc Mentoring Plan (if applicable):
DATA MANAGEMENT PLAN, including dissemination of results:
COLLABORATION PLAN (required for 2 or more PIs):
RESULTS FROM PRIOR NSF SUPPORT (if applicable):
HUMAN SUBJECTS (if applicable):
BUDGET (if necessary):
ADDITIONAL SUGGESTIONS:
PA... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
s***r
发帖数: 238 | 39 I concur. Levi's self-patting has reached a new high:) |
|
b********s
发帖数: 6928 | 40 长，慎入
请教版上各位老师，投稿后收到editor的email，major revision requested，
editor原话是 your manuscript could be reconsidered for publication if you
are prepared to make revisions based on the comments of the reviewers
两个reviewer，reviewer 1 给的comments都很中肯，甚至有表扬在里面，基本我都可
以接纳并按照它去改，可以推断给的最终意见是accept with revision
reviewer 2 从头到尾都在扁这个稿子，说出了 this manuscript does not make
contribution to the literature and the literature review does not show that
this manuscript fills a gap这样的话，并且最后说 I suggest the authors fix
these issu... 阅读全帖 |
|
x*********o
发帖数: 75 | 41 From FastLane:
A program recommendation for award was concurred with by the cognizant
Division/Directorate on 04/25/16. However, no award is ensured and the
recommended duration is 36 months with an effective date of 06/01/16 are
subject to change. The grantee institution assumes any pre-award costs at
its own risk. NSF may request additional information. |
|
|
|
|
|
d*******n
发帖数: 3851 | 46 ☆─────────────────────────────────────☆
gwrfxj (大灰狼) 于 (Fri Mar 25 15:07:21 2011, 美东) 提到:
以前这里的生意很小的时候（或者说每个人之间一次交易量很小的时候），大家都是极
其注意人品的，人品稍稍次一点的，就被大家经常拿出来当典型（比如raint，其实他
也不是那么没品，就是斤斤计较了一些，主要是常常要和姥姥这种道骨仙风的上古神医
比，就没办法了）。为啥当时大家都注意RP啊，不光是个人本身的问题，还有一个大环
境的因素，那就是大家每次的交易量是很小的，你需要很多货的时候，你就要和很多人
打交道，名声坏了，大家都不理你，你就麻烦了。
现在，来的人是越来越多，本身这个林子大了，就是什么鸟都有，大家看到争端越来越
多，也是正常的。加上现在人多，单个交易量也大了，有人就发现，人品其实没什么重
要的。我每次都讲人品，每次都付钱爽快，每次都付高价，有啥用，我资金也不可能周
转过来，货太多了。反之，我不讲人品，每次都要么低价，要么拖欠，反正还是有人来
交易的，同样的资金还可以做更多的事，何乐而不为。大家如果... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
|
|
|
