h*******g
发帖数: 2201 | 1 PM刚回复我的询问,大家有类似的经验吗？
“The review of the above proposal was completed. The panel placed your
proposal in the mid group (Competitive) and not in the Highly Competitive
for funding. Details of the strength and weakness of the proposal including
suggestions by panelists will be available once the recommendation is
approved. Thanks in advance for your patience and understanding. “ |
|
X****5
发帖数: 87 | 2 我们主要用大型数据库或模拟数据。所以当我有有趣想法的时候就着急赶快在电脑上跑
一跑数据，写出文章来投出去。
为了所谓的funding, 不得不吭哧吭哧地写proposal，很难受。
另外，在不需要funding做research的领域，也没有什么funding source。federal
grant的中奖率在2.5%左右（听人说的，不知道怎么算的）。
反正去年算是被写grant proposal 给毁了，真羡慕enjoy写proposal的人啊。 |
|
f*****y
发帖数: 1997 | 3 We propose to study....
I propose to study ...
The PI proposes to study....
哪个更好？
可以混用么？ 我现在是有时候用the PI 有时候写we |
|
c***n
发帖数: 61 | 4 曾经参加过NSF项目评审，我偶然发现有一个proposal以前投过另一个program，无意说
了一下，结果那个proposal被集体否决。
proposals |
|
o****9
发帖数: 479 | 5 “The PM said that (s)he used NSF approved procedures to overturn some of
the
reviewers rating to have my proposal recommended. The ratings of my proposal
were on the two extreme limits of the spectrum -- two E's and two G's. In
normal situation, my proposal had no chance to be recommended.”
以上这段话是你从FastLane上看到的？因为你说了“I did not receive any response
from the PM.”
也就是说PM从来没有向你要过abstract.
我还要一个问题：如果budget and duration没有被要求有任何修改，那PM也得向PI要
abstract吗？是不是说，只有当被要过abstract，PI才能知道将要被fund? |
|
|
n*******l
发帖数: 2911 | 7 我想说的是投proposal就像买彩票，明知道中奖率很低，但是不买就肯定中不了啊。
还是把原文改改，避免歧义。
关于联系NSF PO的问题，关系大不大反正是什么说法都有。我自己是从来没有联系
过。后来我参加Panel时，NSF PO亲自对大家说，投proposal之前跟PO联系也没什
么用，PO不可能给出什么有针对性的建议，顶多告诉申请人，课题是不是适合这个
program。
但是我参加过三次写NSF proposal的workshop，主持人都强调说应该在投以前跟PO
联系一下，谈一谈，问一下看法。现在想想，估计确实也是顶多问问课题是不是合适。
反正我们这种无名小辈，PO一般也记不住，就算记住了也不可能多看几眼。 |
|
y*********i
发帖数: 81 | 8 各位faculty 求指点，写 nsf 的proposal的时候，可以用自己以前的proposal的原句
子么？如果两个proposal有一些相同的部分，这样可以么，比如介绍的部分和研究现状
的部分？多谢指点。 |
|
b**q
发帖数: 86 | 9 自己的proposal寄错了program，被要求withdraw 并re-submit到correct program
announcement。两个program的截止日期都是一样的，而且已过了deadline。有必要
resubmit吗？邮件内容如下。大家有碰到过这样的情况吗？
Dear All,
Please withdraw your proposal to the XXX program, which was submitted to the
wrong Program Solicitation for FY2017 funding. Dr. AAA (program manager's
name) wants you to re-submit under the correct program announcement, which
is NSF 12345. Please let me know, if you have any questions or concerns
regarding your proposal. |
|
s********i
发帖数: 65 | 10 前些天PM发邮件通知我的proposal仍然pending，需要过些日子才能做最后决定。考虑
到当天有同事收到拒信，好像我的proposal进入了所谓的gray zone。不知道这种进入
gray zone的proposal，有多大的可能能中?还请版上的诸位前辈指点。多谢！ |
|
r*****e
发帖数: 620 | 11 比那些直接拒了的proposal中的可能性大，比那些直接fund的proposal中的可能性小
其实就我个人的经验，可能性还是比较大的
但纠结这些可能性有什么意义呢？投出去的proposal就像射出去的箭，你已经没有机会
再改变什么了，不如安心写下一个。等消息中了就好好干，如果没中就改改接着投，不
要患得患失被自己纠缠住。 |
|
a*********8
发帖数: 2353 | 12 看情况，严格的会－－turn down without review。我的亲身经历，送grant的人不小
心错勾了cover page的一个box，其实根本不影响proposal和budget，结果直接拒。
另一次，我在panel，有个proposal和lz类似的格式问题，有人问起，program manager
说－－无所谓了，看proposal的内容。
希望lz碰到第二种。 |
|
j*****r
发帖数: 48 | 13 I respectfully disagree with the other comments.
You should do this, because it is good for you. It exposes you to the grant
review process. Put on your CV, and it shows that the field values your work
enough to ask you to review grant proposals.
If the research is in biomedical field, you may consult the criteria for
reviewing an NIH R01 proposal. Look at Section V in the PA-16-160 document.
You can read the criteria upon which an R01 proposal is scored. |
|
y****6
发帖数: 218 | 14 个人认为，merits里面最重要的就是novelty和originality了。
originality是相对的，因为研究总是建立在过去的东西之上的，这个大部分proposal
都有。
但是novelty是绝对的，大部分proposal是没有的；这个标准把好的和差的就分开了。
novelty这一项是分数权重最高的，除了打分，我还得单独写comments说明为何如此打
分。
别的proposal我不知道，我审的这两个已经通过预审了，所以theme应该是符合的。 |
|
f*****y
发帖数: 1997 | 15 记得看到板上有人问过，也见过不同的回答。
今天想再和大家讨论一下
我个人的感觉是，应该可以用发表过的数据
换一句话说， 我觉得是否可以作为 preliminary data,不在于是否在杂志上发表过，
而是看这个结果对 proposal 里面的 hypothesis 支持的程度
比如， 我最近写一个实验方面的 proposal, 有一个 hypothesis
这个 hypothesis 在我之前发表的一片纯模拟的文章里面验证过了，
但是这还不够， 还需实验室的验证
那么我在proposal 里面可以这样说么：
The preliminary data support the hypothesis. However, there is a need to
conduct experimental studies to provide more conclusive results.
大家觉得可以这样写么？ |
|
y****6
发帖数: 218 | 16 这是我审的第三个proposal，我属于非本领域reviewer。
Proposal写的比较差，根本对已有的research置若罔闻，主PI是烙印，某西部flagship
state university。
我的review summary第一句：I would consider this proposed research a novel
application but lack of originality. |
|
d***a
发帖数: 13752 | 17 Tenure时不会考核这个，只要你能做出成果就行。Proposal中的想法本来就有不确定性
，否则就不是proposal了。但写proposal时别想着吹牛，很容易吹过，呵呵。 |
|
a********e
发帖数: 547 | 18 别人没有明确说review了我的proposal. 但是说对某某课题感兴趣，那个课题正好是我
proposed 的课题。然后我根据对这个领域的了解，认为他很有可能就是review了我的
proposal。
不管怎么说吧，如果我基本可以认定某人是reviewer，然后人家还主动来找我聊，我应
该怎么做？ |
|
m***c
发帖数: 1177 | 19 从来没写过external proposal，看了几份别人的，觉得好像是这样。虽然大佬们一句
话顶我一万句，但是大佬e-mail里的好评也不能在proposal里提吧？还有paper的审稿
意见很好的话，能在proposal里引用吗？ |
|
s********n
发帖数: 1962 | 20 From bloomberg
"The proposal would:
1. Limit the Scope-The President and his economic team will work with
Congress to ensure that no bank or financial institution that contains a
bank will own, invest in or sponsor a hedge fund or a private equity fund,
or proprietary trading operations unrelated to serving customers for its own
profit.
2. Limit the Size- The President also announced a new proposal to limit the
consolidation of our financial sector. The President’s proposal will place
broader li |
|
l**7
发帖数: 3940 | 21 USCIS Proposes to Change TN Period From One-Year to Three-Year
USCIS intends to change the Canadian TN period from the current one-year
period to three-year period. This plan will take time as it will have to
amend the current TN regulation. The USCIS has just initiated the process by
submitting the proposed rule to the OMB yesterday for its review and
approval. Since the clearance will take from 30 days to 90 days, the
proposed rule may not be published for the comment by the public for a while |
|
a*****g
发帖数: 19398 | 22 IL数学教师63届年会接受“围棋数学”proposal
GoMath Academy
--------------
The 2013 ICTM Conference Committee has accepted your proposal for the
October program. It is the intent of the committee to have details regarding
the time and day of this presentation ready sometime in June.
We have your technology needs listed as: 1 LCD
Please contact any other speakers associated with your presentation to let
them know of the proposal decision. Please keep in mind that ICTM only
offers complementary conference registra... 阅读全帖 |
|
h*****r
发帖数: 6 | 23 Spurned proposals possible clue to slaying
EKU HOST FAMILY SAYS WOMAN REJECTED SUSPECT
By Peter Mathews And Delano Massey
HERALD-LEADER STAFF WRITERS
RICHMOND - A former Eastern Kentucky University exchange student who is
thought to have been strangled had recently rejected two marriage proposals
from her boyfriend, who is now charged with murder.
But the host family for 24-year-old Yan Gu said they do not know whether the
spurned proposals led to Gu's death.
Glen Kleine, a former dean of fine a |
|
a*****g
发帖数: 19398 | 24 IL数学教师63届年会接受“围棋数学”proposal
GoMath Academy
--------------
The 2013 ICTM Conference Committee has accepted your proposal for the
October program. It is the intent of the committee to have details regarding
the time and day of this presentation ready sometime in June.
We have your technology needs listed as: 1 LCD
Please contact any other speakers associated with your presentation to let
them know of the proposal decision. Please keep in mind that ICTM only
offers complementary conference registra... 阅读全帖 |
|
e*******e
发帖数: 1837 | 25 I don't think it matters much. Boss can do whatever with the grant after he
gets it, no guarantee the trainee on the proposal will get his salary. My
boss put postdoc's name and biosketch on the proposal if the guy have strong
background related to the proposal (e.g. 20+ pubs in related projects). |
|
s********1
发帖数: 581 | 26 用英文写proposal和paper的问题
老公最近正申请faculty的工作。他以前虽然学了很多写作方法技巧，英语究竟不是母
语，总会有一些表达方式或句子不地道，不准确，给人以Chinese English的印象。老
公当研究生的时候，总有老板，师兄最后把关，指出写作中的错误。真要是当了
faculty,写proposal可怎么办？不可能专门召美国学生到组里做proof reader. 更何况
写paper尤其是proposal都有保密的问题。也不能每次都周professor editing service
. 请问大家有什么好的建议吗？
谢谢大家 |
|
c*****y
发帖数: 122 | 27 【 以下文字转载自 Faculty 讨论区 】
发信人: cliffly (cliffly), 信区: Faculty
标 题: proposal review vs. paper review
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Wed Sep 26 21:05:05 2012, 美东)
最近收到邀请评审一个NSF grant proposal。请问各位有经验的同志们，审grant
proposal和审文章主要区别在哪？
谢谢！ |
|
c*****y
发帖数: 122 | 28 【 以下文字转载自 Faculty 讨论区 】
发信人: cliffly (cliffly), 信区: Faculty
标 题: proposal review vs. paper review
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Wed Sep 26 21:05:05 2012, 美东)
最近收到邀请评审一个NSF grant proposal。请问各位有经验的同志们，审grant
proposal和审文章主要区别在哪？
谢谢！ |
|
a*****g
发帖数: 19398 | 29 IL数学教师63届年会接受“围棋数学”proposal
GoMath Academy
--------------
The 2013 ICTM Conference Committee has accepted your proposal for the
October program. It is the intent of the committee to have details regarding
the time and day of this presentation ready sometime in June.
We have your technology needs listed as: 1 LCD
Please contact any other speakers associated with your presentation to let
them know of the proposal decision. Please keep in mind that ICTM only
offers complementary conference registra... 阅读全帖 |
|
d*2
发帖数: 2053 | 30 http://news.yahoo.com/s/yblog_localsfo/20110411/ts_yblog_locals
By Yahoo! Local – Mon Apr 11, 9:48 am ET
Mary Jo Bowling
Before we delve into the deets behind the mystery proposal that captivated
our readers, let's get a couple of things out of the way: (1) Her name is
Kelly Riplinger and she said "yes" and (2) Jason Fordley, the mastermind
behind the sand art question, might well be the most romantic man in San
Francisco.
On Wednesday at approximately 3 p.m. I posted a blog featuring photos of
... 阅读全帖 |
|
|
t******4
发帖数: 2300 | 32 OLYMPIA, Wash. (AP) - During the 2013 Legislature, lawmakers proposed
raising taxes or fees more than 180 times.
The Columbian newspaper reports 188 bills to raise taxes or fees were
proposed. Those bills would have raised more than $6 billion for the state
if they had passed. Just 35 revenue bills did pass and the Office of
Financial Management estimates they will raise at least $3 billion over the
next decade.
Those numbers come from an analysis by the Washington Policy Center, a
Seattle-based... 阅读全帖 |
|
c*******o
发帖数: 5387 | 33 我没有仔细看，是收到朋友转发的邮件。
听朋友说，有人抱怨,filed complaint， 说现在GTP/AAP里，黑人和拉丁裔孩子特别少
。Fairfax County就决定要在每个中学搞GTP/AAP，这样，黑人和拉丁裔学生就有机会
参加GTP/AAP。
quoted from friend's email:
"...to open new level IV AAP/GTP centers in every middle school and in at
least one elementary school per cluster is the desire to increase access to
AAP/GTP for underrepresented minority students."
"For those of you who don't know enough about this proposal, it is extremely
important for all of us, even if you live in Longfellow MS area. ... 阅读全帖 |
|
i***0
发帖数: 8469 | 34 PROPOSAL REJECTED, ANTITRUST ACTION TO BE FILED
– 2:19 p.m.: In the words of union executive director Billy Hunter, the “
collective bargaining process has broken” and the players have refused the
league’s latest proposal. They have already begun the process to disband
union. But they have not decided to decertify, there is a difference.
The players are filing a disclaimer of interest, an antitrust action against
the league within the next two days. In basic terms, they are taking the
league to ... 阅读全帖 |
|
a*****g
发帖数: 19398 | 35 IL数学教师63届年会接受“围棋数学”proposal
GoMath Academy
--------------
The 2013 ICTM Conference Committee has accepted your proposal for the
October program. It is the intent of the committee to have details regarding
the time and day of this presentation ready sometime in June.
We have your technology needs listed as: 1 LCD
Please contact any other speakers associated with your presentation to let
them know of the proposal decision. Please keep in mind that ICTM only
offers complementary conference registra... 阅读全帖 |
|
t****t
发帖数: 224 | 36 Revolutionary Play Off Proposal
by hinihao and tntttt
All right, this proposal combines hinahao's proposal with some of tntttt's s
uggestions. The original thread got TZT le, so I am re-posting (no pun inte
nded) it here. Bear in mind my english is poor.
hinihao suggested one important criteria for being NC: if you are in a confe
rence, you need to win the conference title first. We will adopt this crite
ria. This ensures fairness to the conference champion.
I have another criteria: if a tea |
|
s*******h
发帖数: 3219 | 37 【 以下文字转载自 LeisureTime 讨论区 】
发信人: pwwp (歪哥), 信区: LeisureTime
标 题: 从《the Proposal》漫谈女性对婚姻和性的憧憬
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Thu Mar 6 21:46:18 2014, 美东)
【简介】从汉武帝他妈嫁入，到电影《the Proposal》再到重归母系社会的思考，漫谈
女性对婚姻和性等的憧憬，兼谈法律和道德规范。
前几天，看电视，重播的一个，《汉武大帝》 ，其中的一集，汉武帝去民间找他妈和
前夫生的一个女儿（金巧巧演的），终于在荒郊野巷的村里找到了，丫头穷的连饭都吃
不起。
然后，汉武帝组织朝会，守着全体大臣，让他妈（皇太后）和女儿相认，母女自然相拥
而泣，汉武帝则对众大臣说，从此以后，这就是朕的皇姐了，你们还不意思意思？ 众
大臣跪拜庆贺皇帝找到姐姐，皇太后找到女儿。
自然，以后这个皇姐姐就是绫罗绸缎，衣食无忧的皇亲国戚了！
于是我感慨一，女人这个投胎啊，真是个学问，不光投胎是学问，嫁人也是。还得讲究
个天时、地利、人和。这就是常说的，女人有两次机会什么的，一次是出生，一次是嫁
人。你... 阅读全帖 |
|
d***y
发帖数: 263 | 38 I wrote the proposal several months before I joined the new lab. I spent a
good of ~2-3 weeks working on the proposal. The first one to two weeks is
just hard thinking on what I want to propose and extensive reading. Try to
think big. Come up with important Q to ask and then think about what specific
approaches to use to answer the Q. An attractive title is very important.
For example, I see sb from Arkin lab has a title "Synthetic Biology with
temporal pathways". I think this is a very sexy |
|
s*********f
发帖数: 155 | 39 Take heart! Every one has tons of rejected proposals.
You got to try!
Sounds like you need to flush out your big picture more. Try to frame your
proposal in the broadest way possible.
Sounds like you need help with English. Taking a writing course could help.
And you need one or two native speakers who can really read the proposal
word by word to weed out your grammar mistakes. |
|
|
k****o
发帖数: 589 | 41 有些实验室要求写proposal，但我不清楚具体要写到何种程度，是像PhD proposal那样
呢，还是类似于grant proposal的形式？请过来人指导一下。多谢！ |
|
s********1
发帖数: 581 | 42 用英文写proposal和paper的问题
老公最近正申请faculty的工作。他以前虽然学了很多写作方法技巧，英语究竟不是母
语，总会有一些表达方式或句子不地道，不准确，给人以Chinese English的印象。老
公当研究生的时候，总有老板，师兄最后把关，指出写作中的错误。真要是当了
faculty,写proposal可怎么办？不可能专门召美国学生到组里做proof reader. 更何况
写paper尤其是proposal都有保密的问题。也不能每次都周professor editing service
. 请问大家有什么好的建议吗？
谢谢大家 |
|
o*****l
发帖数: 203 | 43 一个老板还没面试就要求先写个Proposal看看，问我为什么对他们组感兴趣（这个好回
答），以及有什么想法，把想法写成Proposal。
我擦，最近在密投简历，虽然我的背景跟他课题组研究有一部分交叠，但因为还在准备
其他几个实验室的面试以及目前课题组自己的工作，基本没精力专门为他这个实验室写
Proposal，
各位有没有好的建议阿，
谢谢哇 |
|
g*******e
发帖数: 156 | 44 【 以下文字转载自 Faculty 讨论区 】
发信人: gooooogle (小六子), 信区: Faculty
标 题: 问个问题：NIH R01和NSF Career的Proposal的命中机率一般是多少？谢谢！
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Sun Jan 6 15:29:43 2013, 美东)
问个问题：NIH R01和NSF Career的Proposal的命中机率一般是多少？谢谢！
或者说一般这两个agency的proposal一般fund top ?%？
谢了！ |
|
H*g
发帖数: 2333 | 45 I took a glance at what you have here. I could only contribute my thoughts
regarding of the proposal, but not about oncology.
1. The logic flow of the first 4 sentences in the Abstract is terrible. How
about saying something like (maybe wrong in science and need to be better
rephrased) "Colon cancer is the second most common cause of death from
cancer in the United States. One of factors that contribute to this high
severity is due to its high rate of recurrence. As the source of cancer
recurren... 阅读全帖 |
|
j****1
发帖数: 81 | 46 Thank you very much for the comments. I revised abstract. It's attached
below.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------
Colon cancer is the second highest cause of cancer deaths in the United
States (Markowitz & Bertagnolli, 2009). It is well known that APC (
adenomatous polyposis coli) loss predisposes patients to colon cancer, which
has been primarily attributed to the over activation of Wnt signaling.
Although controversial, can... 阅读全帖 |
|
A********i
发帖数: 97 | 47 【 以下文字转载自 Faculty 讨论区 】
发信人: Allanqunzi (Allanqunzi), 信区: Faculty
标 题: 为什么proposal 和 论文不对 reviewer 隐藏作者信息？
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Thu Jul 2 02:55:35 2015, 美东)
为什么reviewers可以看到作者信息， 而reviewers 自己的信息却被隐藏了？
为什么proposal 和 论文不对 reviewers 隐藏作者信息？
如果双方向隐藏名字，学校等信息的话， 那些牛校老板的proposal 和 paper
是不是就不那么牛了？ 是不是玩儿猫腻的机会就大大减少了？ 这样完全靠idea 和
文章说话， 岂不是更公平？
神圣的学术界为什么不这么搞？？！！ |
|
b*****d
发帖数: 61690 | 48 【 以下文字转载自 Faculty 讨论区 】
发信人: brihand (brihand), 信区: Faculty
标 题: NIH要和foundation合作资助unfunded proposal
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Fri Jun 17 13:20:56 2016, 美东)
http://stm.sciencemag.org/content/8/331/331ed3
Funding unfunded NIH research applications
The Biomedical Research Funding Enterprise Provides The Infrastructure that
leads to new medical products that impact global health. Throughout history,
the long and successful tradition in the United States of investing in
biomedical research involves funding ... 阅读全帖 |
|
发帖数: 1 | 49 http://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/trump-proposes-slashing-medical-research-year-too-n739761
President Donald Trump, who had just proposed slashing the National
Institutes of Health's budget for next year by 20 percent, suggested an
immediate $1.2 billion cut to the agency Tuesday.
The Trump proposals would slice $1.2 billion from a $31.6 billion NIH budget
as it was laid out in the December continuing resolution. They also target
health and science programs across other government agenci... 阅读全帖 |
|
