w********h
发帖数: 12367 | 1 compared to Terrence Tao and Perelman, she is unfortunately nobody...
in her website, there are many "Technical Reports", what are they?
they can be counted as publications? |
|
a****9
发帖数: 418 | 2 come on,
和tao和perelman这样的人比
谁不是nobody
或者我说和牛顿,老爱比,
tao也是nobody
要是Yau这样指点一下江山也就算了,
大家都是普通人, 干嘛和自己过不去 |
|
w********h
发帖数: 12367 | 3 无他，这样的对比有助于提升自己的境界，
别什么小时候考第一名大学100分之类18岁大学毕业22岁哈佛博士之类的还念念不忘，
真正的牛人存在于一个更长的历史空间里，不但影响着周围的仰慕者，
更重要的是影响着一代代人的认知以及人类发展历程。
说Tao和Perelman，不过是因为此文不也是谈数学系的？
任何类似的神化在见识过真正大牛后都类似于笑话。 |
|
s******y
发帖数: 28562 | 4 这个。。。庄听到了会被你气死吧？她一向号称都是做生物物理的。
（注：显微技术是生物物理的一种）
至于说拒绝领奖，那是某些牛叉人的专利，像数学界那个牛人Perelman
都不知道拒了多少奖了，好像连菲尔兹都被他拒了 |
|
j****u
发帖数: 1413 | 5 新闻与照片请见：http://www.ustcif.org/default.php/content/1480/
数学界是全球科学界最复杂纠结的一片“江湖”，恩怨情仇太多！2009年，美国科普作
家哈尔·赫尔曼甚至出版了《数学恩仇录：数学家的十大论战》（Great Feuds in
Mathematics）。数学界与数学家们从来不缺看到了同行相争、师生反目等故事。数百
年前，牛顿和莱布尼兹在在微积分的首创权上产生了激烈争端；天才数学家伽罗瓦为爱
情决斗，21岁早夭。数学家也最热衷排定英雄座次。中国科大数学系首任系主任华罗庚
在世时，华派独步天下。华罗庚逝世之后，苏派大行其道。中国科大数学系多年未有在
校教授当选院士。龚升直到逝世仍未当选院士，丘成桐曾亲自为其抱屈。
然而，全球各大权威学会拥有会士（Fellow）制度多年，美国数学学会（American
Mathematical Society，简称AMS）却无会士制度。2012年，AMS终于不再淡定，决定跟
风为数学英雄推出会士制。
2012年11月1日，AMS宣布其首届会士名单，全球共有约1140位顶尖数学家入选，舒其望
（771）、李... 阅读全帖 |
|
l******e
发帖数: 470 | 6 citation bu tai shuo ming wen ti ba
perelman gu ji citation yi qian ye bu xing ba... |
|
s**********l
发帖数: 8966 | 7 perelman那篇根本不是论文，就是个研究报告，虽然无比牛逼，另外arxiv我们叫做预
印版，已经发表的文章在ieee都找得到，没必要专门发过去吧，我就说计算机的。 |
|
g****t
发帖数: 31659 | 8 本野鸡心理学家认为，老王无论如何折腾都是没用的。
他不可能弥补得了过去他妈对他造成的创伤了。
因为那都是过去的事情了。你没有办法回去过去。
都快博士毕业了还回忆高考军训，可见老王在小时候
受到了多大的伤害。他从一个个学校退学，其实都是
发现就算念了phd对他的目的也是没用的。
就算他去现在再Einstein的办公室坐着的Langlands
工作，那他很快也会发现：不可能让他妈满意。
因为那是过去的他妈。
ref:
http://yinwang0.lofter.com/post/183ec2_47a02c
老王的追求显然不是赚钱吃饭。
但也不可能是对技术有追求。
对技术有追求的，首先要做
的一定是弄好自己的周边环境，乃至行走坐卧。
现在在美国做到这点很容易。另外对技术有追求的人，
很难容忍自己专业上犯基础性概念错误的。自身感知的最敏感的
点就在那几个地方。
【例如：张益唐找了个讲师工作。perelman混了点博士后的工资。
wiles用用以前攒的文章发一发。这些例子非常多的。
美国就是个人傻钱多的地方。】
My suggestion:
Find a doctor since he was... 阅读全帖 |
|
i*****g
发帖数: 11893 | 9 Perelman 有点autism， 伙计们不要搞错啊
那些人的行为不可预测 |
|
d**b
发帖数: 1286 | 10 好不容易混到JHU，UPenn，Yale，UCSF，Chicago，Duke，Columbia，WUSTL，等生物/
医学顶级牛校做千老，却发现除了实验室的有毒试剂和巨大的工作压力让我们短寿，学
校周围乌泱泱的老黑们更让早出晚归的我们随时准备上下班时英勇就义！
附：最新2012 US News医学院排名。
#1 Harvard University
Boston, MA
#2 Johns Hopkins University
Baltimore, MD
#2 University of Pennsylvania (Perelman)
Philadelphia, PA
#4 Stanford University
Stanford, CA
#5 University of California--San Francisco
San Francisco, CA
#6 Washington University in St. Louis
St. Louis, MO
#7 Yale Univers... 阅读全帖 |
|
d*****r
发帖数: 2583 | 11 Zhang Feng以前的老板:
Deisseroth, Karl; associate professor of bioengineering and psychiatry,
Stanford University, Stanford, Calif.
竟然是Associate Professor...就当选院士了，史无前例的Rising Star...
http://www.nasonline.org/news-and-multimedia/news/2012_05_01_NA
News from the National Academy of Sciences
Date: May 1, 2012
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
National Academy of Sciences Members and Foreign Associates Elected
The National Academy of Sciences today announced the election of 84 new
members and 21 foreign associates ... 阅读全帖 |
|
l**********1
发帖数: 5204 | 12 那是 Poincaré 龐加萊猜想的解铃人 俄罗斯数学家 Perelman 佩雷尔曼
//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grigori_Perelman
please go to
//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henri_Poincaré
//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poincaré_conjecture
and
名稱三體問題
英語名稱：three-body problem
N體問題及三體問題的概念N體問題：
N體問題可以用一句話寫出來：在三維空間中給定N個質點，如果在它們之間只有萬
有引力的作用，那麽在給定它們的初始位置和速度的條件下，它們會怎樣在空間中運動。
三體問題：
最簡單的例子就是太陽系中太陽，地球和月球的運動。在浩瀚的宇宙中，星球的大
小可以忽略不記，所以我們可以把它們看成質點。如果不計太陽系其他星球的影響，那
麽它們的運動就只是在引力的作用下産生的，所以我們就可以把它們的運動看成一個三
體問題。
天體力學中的基本力學模型。研究三個可視爲質點的天體在相互之間萬有引力作用
下的運動規律問題。這三個天體的質量、初始位置和... 阅读全帖 |
|
a**********r
发帖数: 41 | 13 comments attached
2012-08-02 06:11 AM
#47837
Iam withNature said:
I tend to side with the opinion and suspicion conveyed in this article and I
am afraid that these concerns have a wider basis than the facts relevant to
the specific Olympic event.
Speaking of this wider problem, I have to reluctantly admit that I myself as
both a faculty member and a researcher have witnessed numerous occasions of
striking dishonesty and lack of integrity demonstrated by my Chinese
colleagues and students on a re... 阅读全帖 |
|
l********k
发帖数: 14844 | 14 红果果的racial profiling
#47837
Iam withNature said:
I tend to side with the opinion and suspicion conveyed in this article and I
am afraid that these concerns have a wider basis than the facts relevant to
the specific Olympic event.
Speaking of this wider problem, I have to reluctantly admit that I myself as
both a faculty member and a researcher have witnessed numerous occasions of
striking dishonesty and lack of integrity demonstrated by my Chinese
colleagues and students on a regular basis.
Lets... 阅读全帖 |
|
p*******1
发帖数: 495 | 15 数学怪才Grigori Perelman就是把他的草稿挂在类似的网站上而被人认可的。
Peer reviewer系统的弊端是显而易见的！ |
|
p*******1
发帖数: 495 | 16 希望在biorxiv.org这上面出现类似Grigori Perelman证明庞加莱猜想这样的牛文，对
生物领域来说可能会很难，但是对阻止少数人劫持整个科研领域来说，这个预印本文献
库显然是利大于弊。 |
|
m*****1
发帖数: 5879 | 17 Benjamin A. Garcia, Ph.D.
Department of Biochemistry and Biophysics
Smilow Center for Translational Research
Perelman School of Medicine
University of Pennsylvania
有没有在 UP 的认识这个教授的？不知道这个教授为人怎么样？ 有认识的说一说，主
要是人品方面有没有什么负面的消息，谢谢。 |
|
H*****u
发帖数: 6 | 18 #1
Harvard University
Boston, MA
#2
Stanford University
Stanford, CA
#3
Tie
Johns Hopkins University
Baltimore, MD
#3
Tie
University of California—San Francisco
San Francisco, CA
#3
Tie
University of Pennsylvania (Perelman)
Philadelphia, PA
#6
Washington University in St. Louis
St. Louis, MO
#7
Columbia University
New York, NY
#8
Tie
Duke University
Durham, NC
#8
Tie
University of Washington
Seattle, WA
#8
Tie
Yale University
New Haven, CT
#11
Tie
New York University
New York, NY
#11
Tie
... 阅读全帖 |
|
q***l
发帖数: 177 | 19 News from the National Academy of Sciences
Date: May 1, 2012
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
National Academy of Sciences Members and Foreign Associates Elected
The National Academy of Sciences today announced the election of 84 new
members and 21 foreign associates from 15 countries in recognition of their
distinguished and continuing achievements in original research.
Those elected today bring the total number of active members to 2,152 and
the total number of foreign associates to 430. Foreign associat... 阅读全帖 |
|
m*****1
发帖数: 5879 | 20 【 以下文字转载自 Biology 讨论区 】
发信人: mxyou21 (小虫爸爸), 信区: Biology
标 题: 打听一个U Pennsylvania 的教授人怎么样
发信站: BBS 未名空间站 (Fri Apr 3 09:57:10 2015, 美东)
Benjamin A. Garcia, Ph.D.
Department of Biochemistry and Biophysics
Smilow Center for Translational Research
Perelman School of Medicine
University of Pennsylvania
有没有在 UP 的认识这个教授的？不知道这个教授为人怎么样？ 有认识的说一说，主
要是人品方面有没有什么负面的消息，谢谢。 |
|
e***t
发帖数: 14386 | 21 好像一般都是top school的教授，学术权威的那种
要不就是准top school的重量级人物...
不像理科的，总有些个非名校或者不是那种特别well-established的，但是
能靠某个发现某个成果留名的
像fields也是，perelman那种工作都丢了的，搁经济学怎么也没戏吧 |
|
j**p
发帖数: 1257 | 22 温瑞安的《布衣神相》有一幕，有个人小鹏功练到12重，大鹏功也练到12重，在名门正
派弟子手下过不了一招。这应该就是武林的常态。
什么时候才会出现这样的情节？某邪派高手只在少林武当之类地方扫过地，然后隐居到
深山老林琢磨绝世武功，一出山就屠灭少林踏平武当。
数学界还有这样的事情，比如Perelman. |
|
g****t
发帖数: 31659 | 23 这不是不在乎钱，是不在乎老婆孩子和父母。国内一年一万，就算不讨
老婆不要孩子，父母生病了怎么办？人不能只为自己活着吧？
Perelman确实是一代宗师，可他39岁了还靠母亲的养老金生存。
如果你想学习这种高人。
那可以开始学GTM52,毕竟学习是从什么时候开始都不迟的......
没错，高明的人有些不大在乎钱。我真有这样的老朋友，觉得搞流体力学理论是一种幸
福。 |
|
|
|
|
a*****c
发帖数: 3525 | 27 1自己怎么不forward去呢？
我来帮一下。 |
|
h*******u
发帖数: 10 | 28 The best one ever appeared here in Mitbbs! |
|
|
i*f
发帖数: 85 | 30 在math版已经re了一次，忍不住还是要再re一次：写的太好了，其它那些乱七八糟的讨
论，都是垃圾 |
|
B********n
发帖数: 22 | 31 引起我灵魂深处的共鸣，为世界上为数不多的理想主义科学家干杯！ |
|
|
|
s****e
发帖数: 2934 | 34 写得好，顶！
这帖子要能上十大就好了，看看现在的十大的帖子，都是垃圾琐事，没人谈正事。 |
|
S*****n
发帖数: 6055 | 35 可怜的wonder啊
我在水木上也看见有人转这个帖子了。。。。。。 |
|
w********h
发帖数: 12367 | 36 News from the National Academy of Sciences
Date: May 1, 2012
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
National Academy of Sciences Members and Foreign Associates Elected
The National Academy of Sciences today announced the election of 84 new
members and 21 foreign associates from 15 countries in recognition of their
distinguished and continuing achievements in original research.
Those elected today bring the total number of active members to 2,152 and
the total number of foreign associates to 430. Foreign associat... 阅读全帖 |
|
d******h
发帖数: 39 | 37 丘成桐：讲讲我从前的学生（田刚）
消息源：科技时空
以前我以为立德跟立言没有关系，但是数十年的观察才知道立德的重要性。立德立功立言
之道，必以谦让质朴为主。
我有一个学生在南京大学电视台访问自炫：「会当凌绝顶，一览众山小」，真轻妄浮夸之
言。其实远山微小，越近越觉其宏大。往往众人合作才能跨过困难的地方，在没有尝试创
作性的学问时，才会说这种肤浅的说话。
(丘成桐: 数学与科技)
我国数学家才华纵横，兼擅独造。早在五十年代末期，华罗庚教授及冯康教授已开拓了某
些领域，走在世界的前沿。当时比较封闭的环境，不但没有妨碍其工作，还使他们走出自
己的道路。
政府过份依赖海外的学者，以他们马首是瞻，会对国内的才俊带来心理的包袱。试举一例
子：
去年数学界宣传的大事，要数是拓朴学中的彭加莱猜想可望解决了。解决的方案基于对理
察汉密尔顿(R. Hamilton)方程的研究。方案是Hamilton提出的，而可望由俄国人普雷尔
曼(Perelman)完成。他对此问题苦思七年，但并没有引起人们的注意。
理察汉密尔顿与我份属老友。早在1996年，我就了解到他工作的重要性了。于是我跑回来
，跟这里的同行说明了这 |
|
l***o
发帖数: 7937 | 38 http://www.popyard.com/cgi-mod/npost.cgi?num=105099&r=0
y Nadejda Lobastova in St Petersburg and Michael Hirst
（Filed: 20/08/2006）
A maths genius who won fame last week for apparently spurning a million-
dollar prize is living with his mother in a humble flat in St Petersburg, co
-existing on her £30-a-month pension, because he has been unemployed
since December.
Grigory 'Grisha' Perelman
The Sunday Telegraph tracked down the eccentric recluse who stunned the
maths world when he solved a ce |
|
B********e
发帖数: 10014 | 39 我考，如果第三点评语是真的，那就是我和Perelman唯一的共同点啦
奖
起 |
|
j******w
发帖数: 690 | 40 这可是Yau自己往身上泊的,
现在全世界可都看着Yau怎么收场. |
|
n******t
发帖数: 4406 | 41 老毛子特点就是一致对外，然后整自己人也不含糊。
当然比起中国人总是首先整自己人要好那么一点点。 |
|
y**m
发帖数: 8 | 42 http://www.usatoday.com/tech/science/2006-08-22-fields-medal-genius_x.htm
看看最后一段：
There is some controversy, however. Two Chinese scientists who have been
fleshing out Perelman's extremely abbreviated and technical work have said
is they who added new ideas and actually completed the Poincare proof.
Russian recluse snubs academic world, rejecting math's equivalent of Nobel
prize
The Poincare conjecture involves topology, a branch of math that studies
shapes.
It essentially says that in three dim |
|
j******w
发帖数: 690 | 43 这可不光是Yau没面子的问题.
可以说是整个中国数学界的耻辱.
曹朱的封顶是在中国的官方报纸刊登的.
以后人家会怎么看待中国数学界?
http://www.usatoday.com/tech/science/2006-08-22-fields-medal-genius_x.htm
看看最后一段：
There is some controversy, however. Two Chinese scientists who have been
fleshing out Perelman's extremely abbreviated and technical work have said
is they who added new ideas and actually completed the Poincare proof.
Russian recluse snubs academic world, rejecting math's equivalent of Nobel
prize
The Poincare conjecture involves topology, a bra |
|
a***n
发帖数: 40 | 44 it is soooooooo long! takes me quite a while to finish reading it. these
reporters are pretty good. I have the impression that they had strong views
in advance, and cited one remark after another from math profs to build
their case. it looks a hack like a closing statement for a trial by a
plantiff lawyer. though, I agree Yau went too far making a big deal of their
effort. Indeed, Cao and Zhu did not make a fuzz of it at all.
A passing note, Perelman won IMO gold at age of 14, a notch better tha |
|
a***n
发帖数: 40 | 45 it is soooooooo long! takes me quite a while to finish reading it. these
reporters are pretty good. I have the impression that they had strong views
in advance, and cited one remark after another from math profs to build
their case. it looks a hack like a closing statement for a trial by a
plantiff lawyer. though, I agree Yau went too far making a big deal of their
effort. Indeed, Cao and Zhu did not make a fuzz of it at all.
A passing note, Perelman won IMO gold at age of 14, a notch better tha |
|
|
o***n
发帖数: 72 | 47 "To do great work, you have to have a pure mind. You can think only about
the mathematics. Everything else is human weakness. Accepting prizes is
showing weakness."
explaining why Perelman refused to accept prizes.
On the country, is A.J.M. Yau's private journal?
I understand what they were doing there. Got it published
as soon as possible and before other people probably Tian Gang?
So as to grab credits. But it takes time for publishing
papers in a decent journal. If you want to show you have d |
|
m*********a
发帖数: 2000 | 48 a silly question:
why do we have such a connection of the topology with a heat-like flow, as
created by Hamilton?
does that mean that the solution to this conjecture is motivated by physics
in some sense? |
|
|
|
